Should I appeal Judge’s decision on renewal fees?

by Readers Question

5 months ago

Should I appeal Judge’s decision on renewal fees?

Make Text Bigger
Should I appeal Judge’s decision on renewal fees?

I went to county court on Friday and the Judge at first said I had not submitted counter claim and that I would not be able to speak. I then told him where my counterclaim was on the papers submitted by the estate agent with my writing on it.

This is what the Judge had in front of him:

1 Two peices of paper neither with my signatures saying first year 10% second 8% third 7%. I pointed out to the Judge how all other forms had my signatures, but these had non.

2 Sheet of paper with the estate agents name and then in tiny writing two lines saying that I agree to all papers sent before by agent presumably the 2 sheets 10% 8% 7%, but no mention of what these papers were also that you have to have a gas check, EPC, electricity cert etc, with my signature at the bottom.

The Judge looked at the two sheets and the signed sheet and makes the decision that I have to pay the renewal fees.

I protested that I have never seen these and that my signature is everywhere but not on these. The Judge he said I have to pay.

I am thinking of appealing and asking if anyone has had a similar case please?



Peter Fisher

5 months ago

It is not easy to say if you should appeal or not without seeing all the paperwork but if the terms of the agent were one sided and unfair then you could look at appealing on those grounds. What defence did you file and did you file a counterclaim. Are you talking of a few hundred pounds or thousands you have to pay due to the Judges decision. An appeal is not cheap either and needs to be filed correctly and in time or will be thrown out at the first hurdle. Did you ask for leave to appeal? You can contact me via my profile on here if you want to discuss further.

David Evans

5 months ago

Did you take your case first to the Ombudsman?? I am appealing renewal fees with Dexters on the following grounds.
One the case in the High Court with Foxtons now limiting fees to two years
the other is
If the landlord is deemed to be “acting as a consumer” he or she will have the protection of the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999/2083 (“UTCCR”). This legislation gives greater protection to consumers. An unfair term may be deemed unenforceable even if the disadvantaged party signed a contract where the offending term was expressly stated.

I believe I am a consumer under the existing law and therefore claim that Dexter's terms relating to a 30-month contract was an unfair term and also asking for an extension of this term for the tenancy been renewed is also an unfair term.
Not sure if that is helpful but this is the basis of my case

Rob Spencer

5 months ago

Reply to the comment left by David Evans at 06/03/2018 - 14:35Apologies if i'm wrong but I think the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts Regulations 1999 were replaced by the more recent Consumer Rights Act on 1 October 2015. At least that is what I had successfully relied on recently when referring to unfair contract terms and conditions in a recent small claims hearing.

David Evans

5 months ago

Reply to the comment left by Rob Spencer at 06/03/2018 - 15:23
Thanks for the update I will amend my complaint


5 months ago

Without seeing the actual papers it's rather hard to pass judgement.


5 months ago

Reply to the comment left by Rob Spencer at 06/03/2018 - 15:23
Only if the contract post-dates the change, otherwise the older legislation applies

Leave Comments

Please Log-In OR Become a member to reply to comments or subscribe to new comment notifications.

Forgotten your password?



Bridging and Development Finance Seminar

The Landlords Union

Become a Member, it's FREE

Our mission is to facilitate the sharing of best practice amongst UK landlords, tenants and letting agents

Learn More