Why the US Rental Market is Miles Ahead of the UK – But Could It Work Here?

After owning a holiday home in Florida for nearly 20 years, my wife and I recently decided it was time for a change. We loved our time there, but the world is a big place, and we wanted to explore more of it. The USA still has plenty of places we’d love to visit, and while we’re also keen to experience the Far East—Japan, Singapore, and the Thai islands are high on our list—we’d still like to return to the States for up to six months at a time every few years. The problem? Hotels or AirBNB’s for that length of time are eye-wateringly expensive, so we started looking at alternative ways to travel and stay comfortably. That’s when we stumbled across Landing, and what we found was astonishing.

The Key Differences: Flexibility vs. Rigidity

In the UK, renting is often a slow, rigid process. You sign up for six to twelve months (sometimes longer). Moving from one rental to another means new deposits, reference checks, setting up utilities, and often furnishing the place yourself. It’s not exactly built for mobility.

In the US, the game is completely different. Large-scale Build-to-Rent (BTR) communities are owned by institutional landlords, offering fully furnished apartments with flexible lease terms. Platforms like Landing, Blueground, and Common make moving between properties incredibly easy—renting feels as seamless as checking into a hotel. The idea of being able to live in multiple US cities over a few months without hassle was something we’d never considered before, but once we did, the possibilities were endless.

How We Could Live in Six US Cities in Six Months

To see just how flexible the US rental model could be, we put together a dream six-month rental adventure—the kind of trip that would be almost impossible under the UK’s rigid rental system. Here’s how it could work:

• Month 1 – New Hampshire (October): Start with the legendary autumn colours of New England, where the trees explode into shades of red, orange, and gold. Crisp morning hikes, cosy coffee shops, and that unbeatable fall atmosphere.
• Month 2 – Nashville (November): Swap the foliage for country music, great food, and Southern hospitality. Nights at the Grand Ole Opry, honky-tonk bars, and trying every variety of Tennessee BBQ.
• Month 3 – Florida (December): Escape the winter entirely and enjoy warm, sunny days in Miami or Orlando. Christmas on the beach? Yes, please.
• Month 4 – Austin (January): Kick off the new year in a city famous for its live music, food trucks, and tech startups. An exciting, creative energy makes Austin one of the most vibrant cities in the US.
• Month 5 – San Diego (February): A laid-back coastal escape, waking up to ocean views, year-round warmth, and fresh seafood.
• Month 6 – Seattle (March): End the adventure in the Pacific Northwest, exploring mountains, sipping coffee in quirky cafés, and enjoying the artsy side of the city.

With Landing, we wouldn’t have to worry about finding furniture, setting up utilities, or navigating rental contracts every time we moved. It’s just book, move in, and enjoy—a concept that feels almost sci-fi compared to how the UK rental market works.

Best of all, renting our home in the Algarve Portugal (a golf course facing modern villa with private pool) to holidaymakers while we are away would cover the entire cost of our trip, including property and car rental and spending money.

The US Build-to-Rent Model: What Makes It Different?

So why does this work so well in the US? Institutional investment. In the UK, most rentals are owned by individual landlords, whereas in the US, large-scale rental communities are developed specifically for tenants. Some of the biggest players include:

• AvalonBay Communities – A massive apartment REIT managing high-quality rental communities across multiple states.
• Equity Residential – A key player in city-centre rental markets, offering professionally managed properties.
• Invitation Homes (www.invitationhomes.com) – Specialising in single-family rental homes—an unheard-of concept in the UK.

These developments aren’t just about providing a place to live; they come with gyms, co-working spaces, swimming pools, and high-end communal areas, making them highly attractive to young professionals and digital nomads.

Why This Would Be a Nightmare to Implement in the UK

So, if the US model is so fantastic, why aren’t we doing this in the UK? Simple—our rental laws are completely different. The US prioritises flexibility, whereas the UK prioritises tenant security.

Here’s why it wouldn’t work under current UK rules: Evictions are much harder – In the US, if a tenant stops paying rent, they can be evicted in weeks, sometimes days. In the UK, eviction can take a year or more, making short-term rentals a risk for landlords.

The result? The UK rental system discourages mobility and makes it incredibly difficult for landlords to offer the kind of flexibility that US rental models thrive on.

What Would Need to Change?

If the UK ever wanted to introduce a membership-based rental model like Landing, major legal reforms would be required. Some key changes could include:

• Simplifying eviction processes – Landlords need the ability to remove tenants efficiently if needed.
• More varied lease structures – Introducing legal frameworks that accommodate month-to-month renting without excessive barriers.
• Encouraging institutional investment – Tax incentives for developers willing to create UK equivalents of BTR communities.

Without these changes, UK landlords will always struggle to offer the convenience and scale seen in the US.

Final Thoughts: A System That Works for Everyone?

I find the flexibility and ease of the US rental model fascinating, but I also see why UK landlords might hesitate to embrace it. The US system works brilliantly for those who want hassle-free, short-term renting, but it comes with trade-offs—weaker tenant protections, higher turnover, and more fluid pricing.

Would I love to see more flexibility in the UK rental market? Absolutely. But would it work under current UK law? Not a chance.

For now, we’ll be watching, learning, and making the most of what’s available. If you’re interested in how Landing and similar platforms work, I highly recommend checking out their website: Landing. Whether you’re a landlord looking at the future or a tenant dreaming of a more mobile lifestyle, it’s fascinating to see just how different renting can be across the Atlantic.

Share This Article