Success for landlord against bully-boy council

Success for landlord against bully-boy council

10:22 AM, 20th November 2020, About 4 years ago 7

Text Size

A client Of Landlord Licensing & Defence who has lived in abject terror for months due to bullying and ridiculous Local Council action had a successful outcome at Court! Terrified by Council Enforcement; a client who had been summoned to court by an overly aggressive North West council for housing offences got a fantastic result.

They had issued 10 summonses against them for Housing Offences which appeared rather overzealous.

With 10 summonses you might think this person was a terrible landlord doing terrible things.

Actually, they are very similar to you and me, just not perfect enough for a heavy-handed enforcement officer – who clearly has no respect for the older generation and their education, when of course they think that “showing their might”  is a better option than guidance and time to implement it.

Like most landlords of a certain older generation so much has changed in the last 10 years it is quite a shock when the council appears at the door of your rented property with good loyal and happy tenants and it is obvious their sole intention is to find fault and culpability – even when there had been no complaints from the happy tenants to investigate nor check the property.

It needed some things doing, definitely, and some time to do them, but like the parking warden standing over the car waiting for the meter time to expire, this officer was waiting to pounce on the said date when He’d demanded the things should be done.

Most were done and the other things were in the process, but still let’s attack and enforce with no regard to the circumstances, and not explaining that they can protest. Just turning up placing the landlord under caution and marching around like a desperate soldier from war looking for anything to accuse them of.

The landlord is someone’s parent. If this officer were a Police Officer he would be suspended.

In a council, he is a glorified leader who takes no excuses from anyone.

There were no complaints from the tenants, and they were living happily and had been for many years, many issues were results of tenant neglect and not reporting as is so often the case.

The property was pretty much like it has been for the last 20 years with regular maintenance when required, all of the things that we all need to certify were in order, so statutory items like gas, electric, etc were all in order.

Of course, every one of us; even in our own homes does not have everything perfect and compliant with Part 1 of the Housing Act 2004 requires, but of course, if we are not in a rented property, they don’t pursue us. But, if someone wants to find something wrong they will find something wrong, just like the thug who looks for trouble can always find it or create it.

Nowadays many power-hungry enforcement officers seem to have watched too many episodes of the 1970s-90s fictitious police and crime dramas and mimic those police from the television in their actions, attitude and nonsense.

The landlord with more than 60 years alive, with no criminal record or blemishes to date, was facing criminal charges and enormous fines (possibly unlimited) because of this situation. The Council’s solicitor had no regard for the person, their fixing everything and ongoing maintenance plans and management plans, no consideration,  just we must prosecute and get them in court.


What was expected to be a quick plea hearing when our client would simply state “Not Guilty”, became a long court case where Good Counsel (yes that is Counsel, not council) A senior Barrister employed by us, worked like an Alchemist; and magically had 5 charges completely dropped and the other 5 left as cases to answer sometime next year.

This legal magician saved our client a fortune in potential fines by getting justice where it was immediately needed – and setting a good ground to answer the remaining charges and over the coming months, which I do believe they will all be dropped too.

This is great news, yet cases like this come across our desks every day and sometimes the client is wise, as this one was and others place the cost of the representations over and above the liberty and possible dismissal of all claims charges and fines.

This is a case where the Landlord was wise to take action and get help, and we see many who attempt to self-defend and make things worse.

The Housing Act 2004 and the Housing and Planning Act 2016 are quite frankly complex and have many consequences that are second nature to firms like ours and the councils and that is why councils are so successful against landlords dealing with them directly when a firm like ours outsmarts them and establishes their incompetence, failings and vileness.

Landlords who choose to self-defend, we generally find self-incriminate and the more they say, the worse it gets, the more they explain, the worse it gets, the more they protest, the more they self-incriminate and so it goes on the more they say, the worse it gets.

The hearing has seen the council fail to secure five nonsense convictions and as a result, we have saved the client the landlord from fines probably between £15,00 and £40,000 as the charges have been withdrawn in those 5 cases.

Please, if you are a landlord and you are in the older generation where so much was different when you started out, as to what it is now, do seek help to check your portfolio is compliant in all areas of the Housing Act 2004, so you do not fall foul of the many laws which are being used against landlords who are relatively good at what they do but not perfect.

They have provided good service for many years and now find themselves not up to date and hence being prosecuted and fined more than most thieves and crooks would be fined, mainly because they have not kept up with housing legislation.

As a landlord myself, I know there is so much to do.  Also as someone who serves other landlords when they make those mistakes that we have all made;  it hurts to see the fines, the prosecutions,  the mental strain and the damage to families these overzealous enforcers create when there are so many better ways to achieve the same result for the landlord and tenant and not use up valuable court time and rectification time and money.

As a landlord, please know the law, know what you’re doing and if you don’t, please seek help and from those who are qualified and that includes agents, property management companies and specialist consultancies such as our firm. Only use those who understand what they are doing, because some just do not.

Yes, and many are excellent too.

In the coming weeks, we will do a webinar with one of our barristers and share with many of you, some of the things we hate about the Housing Act, Council Enforcement and How many landlords can avoid all of this by following some simple rules.

Justice was done in part and still some way to go.

Our thanks go out to the barrister and to our client for what has been a fantastic day in some respects and still leaves a lot of work to be done in the coming months to clear up what is left.

Rest assured the client is happy, the barrister who went to what he expected to be a short plea hearing, fought so well and after 5 hours he had successfully crushed the council nonsense and in the coming months will attempt to do the same to the rest of it. It is so important to have all the preparation done as he did.

As you can appreciate this is an ongoing case, and we will be able to fully report in the future when clear justice is done.

Des  Taylor

Casework Director

Landlord Licensing & Defence

Share This Article



Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

11:34 AM, 20th November 2020, About 4 years ago

Nice story but with no facts, what were the accusations and how were they defended, what was the council's reasoning and what were counsel's defence? Which accusations were dropped and which deferred?

Terence Birch

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

11:37 AM, 20th November 2020, About 4 years ago

Reply to the comment left by David Price at 20/11/2020 - 11:34
I concur with David.
Also, I'm not quite sure of the relevance of the Landlords age?

LordOf TheManor

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

11:47 AM, 20th November 2020, About 4 years ago

What were the 10 summonses against them and when were these issued? It's a bit wooly without this fundamental information.


Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

11:49 AM, 20th November 2020, About 4 years ago

No facts to flesh the story and age irrelevant but the main and really important point is to GET GOOD LEGAL ADVICE. As a retired solicitor, albeit with no conveyancing or L&T experience at all, I can only advise that you must get the best legal help if pursued by any official body. They will have their experienced and cunning team and will try and likely succeed in trapping laymen defending themselves to say just those fatal few words too many. Please be guided and stay safe!


Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

12:31 PM, 20th November 2020, About 4 years ago

You mustn't forget - no one likes to be told their job, Inspectors have to earn their brownie points ! You could have a perfect hs but if a carpet is 1/4 inch to short you are then a criminal !!! You could murder someone and suffer less and I can think of a few! There's no easy way out - if you decide to sell up you're then hammered with taxes. I now consider the authorities to be 'far' worse than any problem tenants!

Mick Roberts

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

14:48 PM, 23rd November 2020, About 4 years ago

That's gonna' be me one day.
They gonna' love to get me, expecting every single house to be perfect as though I was living with each tenant every day. However in real world, every tenant can cause some damage when I'm not there for 6 months.
And I do want to leave all mine with an agent, but the tenants won't let me. And I have to respect their wishes if they've lived there for 23 years no problems.

Luke P

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

0:32 AM, 27th November 2020, About 4 years ago

Which council, please?

Leave Comments

In order to post comments you will need to Sign In or Sign Up for a FREE Membership


Don't have an account? Sign Up

Landlord Tax Planning Book Now