County court for possession claim –  Section 21?

County court for possession claim – Section 21?

9:49 AM, 3rd May 2023, About A year ago 27

Text Size

Hello, I have a tenant who denied that she signed the tenancy receipt document at the court hearing last week. I tried to evict her using section 21.

I have her 10 signatures on different dates during her one year stay. Every signature is different when I compared them after the court hearing.

The judge told her to write a witness statement that she did not sign the receipt document. In other words, she denied receiving How to Rent, the EPC, etc.

How can I prove to the court that the signature is hers?

Thank you,

Aric


Share This Article


Comments

Alison Walker

11:25 AM, 4th May 2023, About A year ago

When I used to do our inventories I would list at the end of the inventory all the documents supplied which I would also present in a folder. Therefore the tenant was not only agreeing to the inventory but was also confirming receipt of all the necessary documents.

Chris @ Possession Friend

12:46 PM, 4th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by Tom Dove at 04/05/2023 - 11:04Yes Tom, that works if ;
Your AST includes an agreement to serve documents via email, and
Tenant responds to email, thereby confirming receipt.
In absence of above, I recommend Post Recorded delivery.

ListedBuilding. org

13:46 PM, 4th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by Tom Dove at 04/05/2023 - 11:04
Firstly - take copies of the passport signature and driving licence and compare with the rent document.
Also - adopt the Chinese standard of a fingerprint next to the signature because then there is no doubt about validity.
And remember....if you can show that the tenant changes signatures all the time, this will in fact go in your favour in Court
....also, as a barrister who has 30 years looking at signature issues, there are commonalities in most of the signatures and I suspect a hand-writing expert (typical cost £300) would have a field day showing the similarities..... then you have the tenant on a witness statement lying and can apply for the judge to consider contempt of court/perjury

Reluctant Landlord

9:42 AM, 5th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by ListedBuilding. org at 04/05/2023 - 13:46
fingerprint - interesting idea! Before I rush off to amazon and purchase a suitable ink stamp pad, are there any woke considerations I need to pay homage to?

Chris100

8:26 AM, 6th May 2023, About A year ago

On the signing page of my tenancy agreement, before the signatures, it says:
'Tenants have received from the landlord the most up to date ‘How To Rent’ and ‘Right To Rent’ documents, current gas and electrical safety certificates, current EPC certificate and the landlord’s Privacy Statement. The tenants’ guarantors have read this agreement.'
So, they are signing to say that they have received everything. I have always assumed that this covered me. Not sure if there's a loophole I've missed.

Mick Roberts

8:33 AM, 6th May 2023, About A year ago

Getting worse in't it.

This Judge will make more homeless, as we hear about these stories & sell up or take only the most perfect tenants next time. Save one current tenant, make it worse & more expensive for the next 1000 tenants.

Mick Roberts

8:34 AM, 6th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by Chris @ Possession Friend at 03/05/2023 - 15:10
Chris, you have it covered as usual, why can't we have u on our shoulder when we doing anything legal. Ooh hang on a minute, in Landlord & tenant world, that would mean every single phone call would be documented with a witness. That's the way it's ruddy going.

Ian Simpson

6:52 AM, 8th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by Tom Dove at 04/05/2023 - 11:04
There seems to be a lot of "what to do next time" advice on here. I do feel for you as getting the s21 upheld is costly, takes ages and the judges will wriggle out of granting the possession order any way they can. The handwriting expert seems a sensible idea though. For my "What to do next time" bit though, we add a clause to the actual AST which says "signature to this document implies receipt of EPC, Gas cert, PI , etc." so all included in the one document...

Nikki Palmer

12:04 PM, 9th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by Chris @ Possession Friend at 04/05/2023 - 12:46
It is never advisable to use Recorded Delivery.

If the tenant doesn't sign on receipt it doesn't get delivered

Chris @ Possession Friend

12:40 PM, 9th May 2023, About A year ago

Reply to the comment left by Nikki Palmer at 09/05/2023 - 12:04
Recorded delivery is only one of a number of means and certainly helps convince the court of 'service'

Leave Comments

In order to post comments you will need to Sign In or Sign Up for a FREE Membership

or

Don't have an account? Sign Up

Landlord Tax Planning Book Now