3 months ago | 2 comments
I own a leasehold flat managed by a managing agent. A prospective tenant wishes to keep one cat.
The managing agent has granted consent, but only on the basis that: “The cat must be a house cat and must not be allowed to wander the communal areas at any given time. Should the cat be reported to be seen in the communal areas at any given time this consent will be revoked.”
My concern is practical enforceability. The development is surrounded by residential properties and there are other cats regularly seen in and around the grounds. It would be difficult to establish whether a cat seen in a communal area was actually the tenant’s cat or one belonging to neighbouring properties.
Under the Renters’ Rights Act, landlords and managing agents are expected to consider pet requests reasonably and not rely on blanket restrictions. Tenants can request permission to keep a pet and consent should not be unreasonably withheld.
Has anyone encountered similar conditions? Would a consent term that could effectively be revoked based on an unverified sighting of a cat be regarded as reasonable, particularly where there is no reliable way of identifying whose cat it is?
I’d be interested in views from both landlords and leasehold specialists.
Thanks,
Amanda
11 comments on this article
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
3 months ago | 2 comments
5 months ago | 6 comments
2 months ago | 3 comments
Member Since February 2024 - Comments: 127
10:03 AM, 30th October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Is the managing agent the superior leaseholder, that is to say the owner of the property? To my knowledge, the conditions of the lease set by the owner takes priority over any letting agent’s decision. if the owner’s conditions says ‘no pets’, then that’s that!
Member Since April 2018 - Comments: 739
10:04 AM, 30th October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Firstly your managing agent should have at least asked you if you would grant permission as it is your flat you are really concerned about. However it seems to be an interesting directive as obviously the cat will wander in the communal area (garden), but it would still be difficult to enforce that unless the lease states so.
Member Since May 2017 - Comments: 865
10:28 AM, 30th October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
I think having a ‘house cat’ is cruel and should not be allowed
Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1437
10:40 AM, 30th October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
I would write back to the agent to say that you can’t guarantee that the cat will be kept indoors or that the tenant would remove the pet in the event of the consent being revoked. I would also make clear that legislation would make it practically impossible to evict a tenant under these circumstances and in light of this, what is their answer to the tenants request to keep a cat.
Member Since October 2022 - Comments: 445
12:33 PM, 30th October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Your lease is the legally binding contract setting out the conditions which allow you to live in your flat. Does it allow you to sublet and if so are there conditions. The managing agent is contracted to the freeholder or superior leaseholder to enforce the covenants in your lease. So I would ask the MA on whose authority they give this advice because if MA not acting with authority of FH/SL then there could be issues later , and the FH/SL cannot differentiate between one LH and the other LHs.
Member Since September 2026 - Comments: 62
6:59 AM, 31st October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Hi Amanda,
It’s worth separating two questions here, because they don’t have the same answer. Whether the agent can impose this at all, and whether anyone could ever act on it.
On the first, start with your lease rather than the Act. The Renters’ Rights Act makes a refusal reasonable where your own superior lease forbids pets and the freeholder won’t consent, so the head lease is what’s really driving this. Ask the agent to point you at the actual covenant. If there isn’t a pets clause in it, they’re inventing a restriction and conditioning something they don’t control.
On the second, look at who is exposed. The agent has no contract with your tenant. Any enforcement runs to you as leaseholder, and on a long lease that means a section 168 determination under the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Act 2002 before forfeiture is even on the table. That’s a high bar on a cat sighting nobody can attribute.
The sting is that revocation leaves you stuck. You’d be in breach upstream with no realistic way to make the tenant rehome the animal.
So I’d get the wording changed. Revocation only on evidence it’s your tenant’s cat, and an obligation to take reasonable steps rather than an automatic withdrawal.
OJ
Member Since October 2022 - Comments: 445
9:07 AM, 31st October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
To clarify: you can almost never use revocation to end a residential lease. A landlord must navigate the complex heavily regulated statutory route of forfeiture which absolutely requires section 146 for non rent breaches.
Member Since October 2017 - Comments: 125
12:50 PM, 31st October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
I am in discussion with the Managing Agent as the tenant has requested a pet. They have come back with the clause that no animal can be kept without written permission of the Lessor which can be revoked at any time. I have requested that they ask for permission. It is well past the 28 days in which I should have responded to my tenant. I have chased up, now including the point from DPT that I would probably be unable to remove the pet or tenant if permission was revoked. I also questioned if some leaseholders could be granted permission and others refused. (There are a few pets in the block already).
Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1437
1:37 PM, 31st October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Reply to the comment left by Cathie at 12:50
If the managing agent just reiterated the terms and handed the issue back to me, I would write to the tenant and decline the application on the basis that the MA is proposing to impose terms that I can’t meet and that could affect my lease.
I would suggest a holding response in the meantime and checking the MA’S authority to impose the condition
Member Since October 2017 - Comments: 125
1:53 PM, 31st October 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Reply to the comment left by DPT at 31/10/2026 – 13:37
Thank you. I have written to the tenant with their response and they have requested that I ask the freeholder for permission. Having included your comments in my chase up, I think (hope) the freeholder will not grant permission.