3 weeks ago | 100 comments
This morning I wrote a response to an article by the Landlord Crusader about tax. It was lengthy full of figures and probably the most boring read ever posted.
A like-minded Chartered Accountant was however able to get through it and his comments were food for thought. I think the message may be better and more interestingly conveyed by three simple questions. If you want the detail, read the response in the Landlord Crusader post 29th October.
To the tenant who rented that house for 15 years:
“The home you lived in carried about £190,000 more tax than it would have if you’d owned it, around £1,000 a month, and that tax has to come out of your rent. Does that surprise you? Do you think it’s fair?”
To the landlord who let it:
“You paid about £213,000 in tax on your tenant’s home. Had it been taxed like an owner-occupier’s home, it would have been about £20,000. Do you agree that your tenants need all the help they can get, and that fairer tax would mean better value for them and a more competitive private rented sector?”
To the politicians who made it possible:
“Your own forecaster, the OBR, warns that your latest tax rise could push rents up. Do you accept that taxing landlords this heavily means higher rents for tenants who can least afford them?”
It looks to many of us like the line of least resistance. Taxing owner-occupiers the same way would be political suicide, so landlords take the hit.
And the constant vilification of landlords hides where the cost really lands: on tenants.
It also hides the real reason we’re in this mess. Successive governments have failed to build enough homes.
If you agree please give a like, and of course comment if you wish.
Thank you,
Hugh
6 comments on this article
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
3 weeks ago | 100 comments
3 weeks ago | 26 comments
3 weeks ago | 2 comments
Member Since June 2019 - Comments: 1002
11:08 AM, 2nd November 2026, About 3 weeks ago
I would say that successive governments have failed to get a grip on immigration, the uk population was set to stabilize before we became the world’s dumping ground.
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 3460 - Articles: 83
11:08 AM, 2nd November 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Annoys me how these bafoons don’t listen.
Chancellor Healey said we’ve gone after Property Tax instead of income tax.
Hang on, it’s income Tax we pay u Nana. Which if increases & numbers don’t add up, we squeeze the rent when many of us don’t want to squeeze the rent. Yes some Landlords put up to get as much as they can. Many of us don’t if covering our costs. When not covering the costs, we can no longer help the tenant u bafoons.
Member Since June 2017 - Comments: 2
12:59 PM, 2nd November 2026, About 3 weeks ago
I holeheartedly agree with Mick Robert’s, successive governments have taxed us Landlords as we are any easy touch, yet we are providing housing that is not readily available via local Councils or Housing Associations. Is there no wonder that so many private Landlords are leaving!
Member Since March 2024 - Comments: 380
1:21 PM, 2nd November 2026, About 3 weeks ago
I wonder if George Osborne still believes what he came out with in 2015? Stating that owner occupiers paid more tax than landlords and likening landlord offset of interest against taxable rental income to the previous owner occupier ‘MIRAS’ – which is the ultimate comparison of apples with bananas.
This wasn’t just the usual disingenuous utterance of a politician. It was truly moronic and responsible for the introduction of Osborne’s S24 along with SDLT premium (and a specific higher CGT rate for residential property that landlords have only been technically let off because it suited Reeves to raise the standard rates up to the previous residential property only rates). And of course laid the foundation stones for the problems many tenants and would be tenants have today of high rents and scarcity of properties.
Member Since January 2023 - Comments: 361
2:18 PM, 2nd November 2026, About 3 weeks ago
Hate to say it but the Blair era was best for property and he got decent GDP growth too. Cheri Blair even helped on the S24 legal challenge
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 849 - Articles: 1
10:43 AM, 5th November 2026, About 2 weeks ago
Reply to the comment left by Crouchender at 02/11/2026 – 14:18
dont think she achieved anything though