VAT Bombshell for Serviced Accommodation: Upper Tribunal Ruling Shakes the Industry

VAT Bombshell for Serviced Accommodation: Upper Tribunal Ruling Shakes the Industry

9:20 AM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago 6

Text Size

“This ruling could spell financial disaster for operators and property owners alike.” That’s the message echoing across the serviced accommodation industry following a dramatic reversal by the Upper Tribunal (Tax and Chancery Chamber) in the HMRC v Sonder Europe Ltd case. The decision has shattered assumptions about VAT treatment under the Tour Operators’ Margin Scheme (TOMS), leaving business owners scrambling to assess the impact.

A Game-Changer for VAT in the UK Serviced Accommodation Sector

The Tribunal’s decision has drawn a clear line in the sand: if your business rents long-term residential properties, makes modifications, and then sublets them as short-term lets, you may no longer be able to rely on TOMS. Instead, you could face full VAT liability on your supplies.

For serviced accommodation providers, the stakes couldn’t be higher. “We’re talking about a potential 20% increase in VAT costs for many operators,” warns one industry insider. “Margins are already tight, and this ruling could push businesses to the brink.”

The Case That Shook the Sector

Sonder Europe Ltd, a key player in the serviced accommodation space, leased residential properties on long-term contracts and transformed them into stylish short-stay apartments for travellers. Their argument? That these operations qualified for TOMS, allowing VAT to be calculated on the profit margin rather than the full transaction value. Initially, the First-tier Tribunal agreed.

But HMRC appealed—and won. The Upper Tribunal concluded that Sonder’s activities didn’t meet the criteria for TOMS. The decision rested on three key points:

  1. Direct Benefit: Long-term leases taken by Sonder didn’t directly benefit travellers but were instead “in-house” services.
  2. Modifications: The properties were significantly altered, undermining TOMS’ requirement for minimal processing.
  3. Consistency: By converting exempt residential leases into standard-rated short-term lets, Sonder’s operations failed to align with TOMS.

“This ruling will leave operators paying VAT on their entire revenue instead of just the margin,” explains one tax specialist. “That’s a crushing blow for the business model of many providers.”

What Does This Mean for Owners and Operators?

The ripple effects of this decision will be felt far and wide. Property owners who lease to operators on long-term contracts may face reduced demand as businesses reassess their models. One landlord we spoke to admitted, “I’m worried my tenants will struggle to afford the new VAT burden. If they go under, I’m left with empty properties.”

Operators, meanwhile, are staring down the barrel of skyrocketing costs. “This ruling doesn’t just hit our bottom line—it could destroy our ability to compete with traditional hotels,” said a leading serviced accommodation provider. “We might have to pass these costs on to guests, and that’s not a sustainable option.”

And what about the holidaymakers themselves? “Guests could soon find short-term lets becoming as expensive as hotels,” predicts another operator. “What made this market so attractive was the affordability and flexibility. That advantage could vanish overnight.”

Comments Section Spotlight: How Will This Impact You?

We want to hear from you. Are you a property owner leasing to serviced accommodation operators? An operator trying to keep your business afloat? Or a holidaymaker concerned about rising prices? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Here’s what we’d like to know:

  • How will this ruling affect your business or investment strategy?
  • Do you think the government should intervene to protect this sector?
  • Are there creative ways for operators to absorb the VAT costs without passing them on?

Supreme Court Appeal: Tactical Play or Genuine Hope?

With the deadline for appealing to the Supreme Court looming, industry insiders are speculating whether Sonder Europe will take the case further. A Supreme Court appeal could buy the sector time, maintaining the current VAT treatment while the case is reviewed.

“Even if Sonder doesn’t believe they’ll win, an appeal might be worth it as a delaying tactic,” suggested one commentator. “It would give operators and owners a window to restructure and adapt.”

Restructuring options could include:

  • Shifting business models to align with the Upper Tribunal’s interpretation of TOMS.
  • Revisiting lease agreements to minimise exposure to VAT liabilities.
  • Exploring corporate structures that mitigate the financial impact of the ruling.

However, a Supreme Court appeal also carries risks. If unsuccessful, it could solidify the Upper Tribunal’s ruling as binding precedent, making it even harder for businesses to challenge HMRC on similar grounds in the future.

“The stakes are enormous,” said one legal commentator. “An appeal could buy precious time, but it’s a high-risk gamble.”

“This ruling feels like a hammer blow,” said one operator. “If we don’t adapt, the entire industry could change beyond recognition.”

Let’s keep the discussion alive. Share your thoughts, strategies, and questions below—and let’s work together to navigate this seismic shift.


Share This Article


Comments

GlanACC

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

9:35 AM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago

Fair do's .. it was another 'grey area' that operators tried to exploit and they have come unstuck.

Robert M

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

9:58 AM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago

This is presumably a big blow to the "rent to serviced accommodation" business model, as it potentially adds a 20% VAT charge onto the operators' rental income figures (which presumably would, in most cases, need to be passed on to the consumers/customers/renters).

However, does it have the same effect on owner landlords that operate their own serviced accommodation? (i.e. not leased to any middleman SA operator).

Mark Alexander - Founder of Property118

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

10:07 AM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago

Reply to the comment left by Robert M at 21/01/2025 - 09:58
No, it doesn't

Jill Church

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

10:11 AM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago

If their turnover is less than £150k pa , holiday accommodation operators can use the Flat Rate scheme to calculate the VAT due. The rate is 10.5%. Its very straight forward scheme to use, just multiply your income by 10.5%.
They are unable to claim the VAT on expenditure with some exceptions such as for a "capital expense".
These schemes are designed to save admin for a lower turnover trader whilst setting a reasonable amount due to HMRC.
This maybe an option for some traders affected, but the larger concerns with turnovers exceeding £150k will need to declare 20% VAT on their sales and then reclaim VAT incurred on their costs.
There maybe a little glimmer, if they let to same person for longer term part of the income ( after 28days) can be classed as "exempt".

Bernard Mealing

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

12:41 PM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago

How will this affect 'SERCO' and the other bigger rent to rent companies.....??? be very interesting...So if we rent to the council what are the implications. for the property owners...??

Jill Church

Become a Member

If you login or become a member you can view this members profile, comments, posts and send them messages!

Sign Up

16:02 PM, 21st January 2025, About 4 weeks ago

Reply to the comment left by Bernard Mealing at 21/01/2025 - 12:41
SERCO or the Council are more likely to be using properties for longer term residential lettings and will issue tenancy agreements so therefore not subject to VAT.
Generally VAT only applies to short term lettings, such as holiday lets.
However there shouldn't be any VAT implications for the property owners whoever they let to as their rental income will still be "exempt".

Leave Comments

In order to post comments you will need to Sign In or Sign Up for a FREE Membership

[nextend_social_login provider="facebook"] [nextend_social_login provider="twitter"]
or

Don't have an account? Sign Up

Landlord Automated Assistant Read More