Shelter’s new strategy document contains a number of untruths

Shelter’s new strategy document contains a number of untruths

8:49 AM, 26th October 2018, About 5 years ago 7

Text Size

‘Does the truth not matter to them?’ click here

Earlier this month the commercial charity Shelter issued a new strategy document. click here

The following quotations are taken from section 6. entitled “Rights for renters and an end to discrimination”:

“In the last two decades, as home ownership and the number of social homes have fallen, there has been an explosion in the number of households renting privately”

The first part is untrue. In the last two decades the number of owner-occupied dwellings increased by just over a million in England, and by 300,000 in Scotland and Wales.. This can be seen from Tables 102 and 104 which can be downloaded click here.

“In fact, the ending of a contract by a private landlord is now the leading cause of homelessness across the UK.” In fact, Shelter’s directors know that this is tautological nonsense,  Shelter’s own website says it is not a cause at all, never mind the leading cause. Click here

“We are not against private renting” Readers are invited to judge whether this is true or not.

Our ground-breaking campaign to end the practice of so-called ‘No DSS’ adverts will be at the heart of our fight to end discrimination against those on benefits right across the housing system. This practice is unethical and unlawful.”

It is not unlawful. Shelter’s Director of Communications said on TV that this has not been established in a court of law, and a discrimination lawyer next to him confirmed it. Click here

“Shelter has unrivalled expertise in housing law, and our lawyers are fighting daily for the right to a home. [No matter how anti-social the tenant, or how many months of rent arrears: Click here] Now we will develop our use of strategic litigation to focus this expertise on issues where winning one case can change thousands of lives. We are already bringing a series of cases to highlight the unlawful nature of ‘No DSS’ practices.”

Winning such a case will not change thousands of lives for the better. Removing an alleged blanket ban, whose existence has been denied by the main agent accused by Shelter, click here will not make a single home available to benefits claimants that wasn’t available to them before. All it will do is raise their hopes in vain, and waste their time in establishing that they can’t afford the rent.

“We will campaign for improvements in conditions and consumer protection, and we’ll press the government to establish a genuine right to stay for renters who want enough security to be able to put down roots, or for their child to be able to stay in one place to complete their schooling [What 13 years?]. The UK government’s proposal for longer three-year tenancies in England is a welcome first step towards this right, but we cannot see any justification for England continuing to allow no-fault evictions when Scotland has already abolished them.”

Shelter doesn’t think 3-year tenancies would be sufficient. It wants Section 21 to be abolished so that tenants can stay for life. That will not improve their security; on the contrary, they will be evicted as landlords rush to leave the market. The PRS will shrink dramatically and as a consequence rents will go up, so those who aren’t made homeless will have to pay more.

Any claim made by Shelter should be treated with extreme caution.

Share This Article



9:54 AM, 26th October 2018, About 5 years ago

This is just a conglomeration of specious rhetoric to attract/justify/encourage the donations.
This document has nothing to do with actually providing a roof over homeless peoples heads.

Chris @ Possession Friend

9:59 AM, 26th October 2018, About 5 years ago

Good article Appalled L, keep them coming. Any help you need, just ask.

Dr Rosalind Beck

12:06 PM, 26th October 2018, About 5 years ago

Shelter is such a destructive organisation. If only the wider public and Government would realise it and cut the funding and give it to actual providers of homes.


19:31 PM, 26th October 2018, About 5 years ago

Maybe property118 should contact the BBC and proposed some of these facts


10:14 AM, 29th October 2018, About 5 years ago

Yes absolutely, Shelters media manipulations and plain wrong headed policies must be rebutted and challenged. We need much more media exposure and much more determined lobbying. Time for the big minds and players in the PRS to step up and support Larry’s Landlord Alliance.

Appalled Landlord

14:50 PM, 6th March 2019, About 4 years ago

Beales is still misrepresenting the law:

“This piece has been updated on 4/3 and paragraph six has been edited to remove the statement that these practices are ‘unlawful’ ”

Appalled Landlord

21:52 PM, 22nd March 2019, About 4 years ago

Apparently, lying to the public was normal in the previous charity that Polly Neate ran.

Leave Comments

In order to post comments you will need to Sign In or Sign Up for a FREE Membership


Don't have an account? Sign Up

Landlord Tax Planning Book Now