2 months ago | 43 comments
Tenants should be given the right to carry out repairs and deduct the cost from their rent, while landlords who exaggerate deposit claims should face penalties, a renters’ group has demanded.
Generation Rent has put forward a series of proposals to improve life for tenants as part of a cross-party initiative launched by MoneySavingExpert founder Martin Lewis.
The initiative invited the public to suggest practical, low-cost changes that could make everyday life better across the UK, with housing among the key issues raised.
The calls come in the wake of the Autumn Budget, which will see tax rates on property and savings income rise by a further two percentage points from April 2027, on top of an increase announced by Rachel Reeves last year.
Generation Rent claims many tenants are forced to pay for repairs themselves, with little clarity over whether or how they can recover the costs from their landlord.
The group is calling on the government to introduce a clear legal right for renters to arrange repairs and deduct the cost from their rent.
Under its proposal, landlords would also have to provide a valid reason for refusing the work, while tenants would need to supply evidence of the costs incurred.
Generation Rent explains in the proposal: “Giving renters a clear legal right to arrange repairs ourselves and deduct the cost from their rent would give us a quicker and more straightforward way to get essential repairs carried out in our homes.
“It should be unnecessary for tenants to seek multiple quotes for the work to be done as, by ignoring the problem, the landlord has forfeited their right to insist on value for money. The government could include this right as part of Awaab’s Law, currently subject to consultation.”
The group is also calling for landlords and letting agents to face fines for making exaggerated or unfounded claims against tenants’ deposits.
Generation Rent claims the current tenancy deposit protection system allows landlords to make inflated claims without facing any penalties, even when those claims are rejected.
In its submission, the group proposes fines for landlords and letting agents whose substantial claims against tenancy deposits are rejected by protection schemes on more than one occasion.
In its submission the tenant group explains: “A single case of this happening may be an aberration, but repeated cases indicate a pattern of behaviour that has the potential to harm other tenants who do not feel confident in disputing a claim with the scheme.
Fear of penalty would lead to more realistic claims, return more money more quickly to tenants, free up resources within schemes, and disincentivise bad behaviour by landlords and letting agents.”
As previously reported by Property118, cleaning was the biggest reason for tenancy deposit claims in 2025, accounting for 29.38% of claims handled by The Deposit Protection Service (The DPS).
Other proposals include making it easier for renters to compare the true cost of different properties by including energy bills and council tax information in the upcoming Private Rented Sector Database.
Generation Rent also wants a new service to help tenants remain in their homes when their landlord decides to sell.
It suggests a government-run website that would match tenants facing eviction because of a sale with landlords looking to buy properties with tenants already in place, as well as lenders specialising in helping renters buy their homes directly from their landlords.
15 comments on this article
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
Previous Article
Telford landlord fines and new HMO planning restrictionsNext Article
London renters hit by soaring rents as costs soar
2 months ago | 43 comments
1 month ago | 8 comments
2 months ago | 9 comments
Member Since February 2024 - Comments: 127
11:47 AM, 19th November 2026, About 6 hours ago
If the tenant uses an approved tradesman and has approval from the landlords for the job that’s fine, but quotes and invoices and evidence of the work done must be presented before the landlord ‘has to’ pay the bill.
Recently a tenant complained because the shower pressure was low, so I called out my plumber, at my expense and went over to see what the tenant meant by ‘low pressure’ … well it seems that from an electric instant hot water shower, the tenant wanted a power shower at very hot temperatures…. and actually , truthfully at normal shower temperatures the plumber and I agreed the pressure ws reasonable.
So under this idea, the tenant could have asked for a several thousand pound job to link a power shower to the boiler ??? When the tenant was perfectly aware of the electric instant shower when they agreed to rent the house.
There has to be a clear distinction between a ‘repair’ to an existing system and a tenant who is trying to milk the landlord for everything they can get. This particular tenant also commented on some movement of the vertical blinds when the last storm was raging, but couldn’t be bothered to say whether it was from the window itself or around the window. but she expected me to come and ‘fix it’.
Frankly there are tenants, and we have all had them, that treat the landlord as a servant and think the landlord is at the beck and call of their whims .
Member Since October 2026 - Comments: 1
1:30 PM, 19th November 2026, About 4 hours ago
It would only happen once
Member Since January 2015 - Comments: 1669 - Articles: 1
2:00 PM, 19th November 2026, About 4 hours ago
If the tenant(s) organises and pays for the repairs, even if deducts from the rent, then the repair contract is with them and the contractor/company not the landlord with the contractor/company.
So when the repair fails or is shoddy or does not pass Local Authority inspection the tenant must be the one legally liable to rectify.
Member Since April 2018 - Comments: 739
4:48 PM, 19th November 2026, About 1 hour ago
Reply to the comment left by Judith Wordsworth at 19/11/2026 – 14:00
But when it all goes wrong between the tenant and contractor, the council will chase the landlord because the system is rigged.
Member Since January 2025 - Comments: 149
5:12 PM, 19th November 2026, About 46 minutes ago
Reply to the comment left by Reluctant Landlord at 19/11/2026 – 11:18
… you’re wrong. The Renters’ Rights Act 2025 effectively transfers to tenants and the state a beneficial interest in privately owned property on a scale unprecedented in modern property law. Legal ownership is reduced to little more than a token title, while the capital investment, financial risks, liabilities, maintenance obligations and responsibility for continued supply remain firmly with the legal owner.
It is a magnificent piece of legislation, brilliantly engineered and brought together in plain sight, while industry representatives have collected fees and feebly played catch-up, advising their members how best to comply with regulations that progressively strip away the real value of their assets.
It is the peacetime equivalent of the wartime requisitioning of private property, but with an ingenious twist: the state takes control of the benefits while leaving the costs, risks and obligations with the owners, who must continue providing the assets.
Imagine the public outcry if the Government compelled private car owners to make their vehicles available for others to get to work, while obliging the owners to continue paying for the finance, insurance, maintenance and depreciation. Yet the same fundamental principle is being applied to private rented housing with remarkably little resistance.
The difference is that landlords have been so successfully demonised by the media and political establishment that the erosion of their property rights attracts sympathy for those receiving the benefits rather than those bearing the costs. Meanwhile, an industry that should have mounted a united and formidable defence has largely confined itself to selling advice on how to surrender those rights more efficiently.