Can I evict a tenant from a 2004 tenancy without a protected deposit?

Can I evict a tenant from a 2004 tenancy without a protected deposit?

Eviction notice beside piggy bank and deposit form highlighting tenancy deposit issues
12:01 AM, 28th November 2025, 5 months ago 10

I have had a tenant since Oct 2004. I gave him Section 9 notice to quit, which expired 30th Sept 2025. I have allowed him extra time to find a home, mainly as he can only afford council property, and it took a while for him to register to bid due to the council giving him incorrect advice on the validity of the S9.

I am now looking to proceed with court action, either using a legal firm or doing it myself. However, whilst researching the process, it states that the deposit must have been paid into a deposit scheme before it can go to court, but requirements for deposit schemes only applied to tenancies starting after April 6th 2007.

Where do I stand? I would like to add that this is not a malicious notice to quit, it’s simply I need to get nearer to market rent, which is £450 pcm more than he is paying.

I am trying to help him as much as I can, but I need to put pressure on the council to move this along for him.

Thanks

EC


Share This Article

Comments

  • Member Since January 2022 - Comments: 97

    5:50 PM, 28th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    Just to clarify, did you take a deposit?
    If so where is it?
    I would in all honesty, return the deposit, if you have one, it might help your tenant move, it will defo not help you, if you have a non protected deposit, google how much the court could rule for you to pay your tenant….
    You will not put pressure on the Council, never, ever, they serve themselves, not the Public and defo not Landlords (AKA the Enemy) Are there any housing associations he could try?

  • Member Since April 2014 - Comments: 985 - Articles: 2

    7:09 PM, 28th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    Serving a section 9, I assume you are gaining possession from an asylum seeking tenant(?). As such, you do not need to protect a deposit if the tenancy was granted for this purpose. Providing accommodation under the Immigration and Asylum Act 1999, is not an assured or assured shorthold tenancy. However, the act was updated in 2000 and I’m not familiar with those changes.

  • Member Since April 2014 - Comments: 985 - Articles: 2

    7:41 PM, 28th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    Please disregard my previous answer. Things have changed and although the tenacy agreement may not be an AST, the same deposit protection rules apply. Im just wondering what else has changed and whether a section 9 is still the means for seeking possession.

  • Member Since April 2014 - Comments: 985 - Articles: 2

    8:19 PM, 28th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    Hi EC, I don’t think you have provided sufficient info to get a reliable response. It’s a bit of a minefield. You need to provide more information about the exact legal basis under which the accommodation is provided. AST or otherwise. What type of accommodation is it (e.g., Home Office asylum accommodation, local authority housing, private rental etc), and what is the current immigration status of the occupant (asylum seeker, failed asylum seeker, or granted refugee status)?

  • Member Since January 2023 - Comments: 36

    8:54 PM, 29th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    The council will advise your tenant to stay put because they will have nowhere to put him. Its up to you to move things forward. If I were you I would serve a section 21 while you still can. You will probably still have to go to court to get bailiffs to move him because he is not going to go of his own accord. The lack of deposit should not be an issue because legally 20 years ago you didn’t have to log it with a deposit protection company. If I were you I wouldn’t hesitate to hurry things along while the situation is still amicable, it will only get more difficult with the change of tenancy law.

  • Member Since July 2013 - Comments: 1266 - Articles: 1

    9:16 AM, 30th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    For the hassle versus goodwill, after 20 years just increase the rent gradually. I have a similar tenant in terms of length and shortfall and wouldn’t even consider ending the tenancy

  • Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1171

    4:32 PM, 30th November 2025, About 5 months ago

    Is this an assured agricultural tenancy? I’m afraid I dont have any information about section 9 notices, but I believe that landlords who took deposits prior to 2007 had to protect them from 23 June 2015 due to the Deregulation Act. A failure to do so would render a s21 notice for an AST invalid for example.

  • Member Since January 2025 - Comments: 1

    10:13 PM, 2nd December 2025, About 5 months ago

    Deposits paid before April 6, 2007, generally did not need to be protected unless the tenancy was renewed or became periodic after that date. If the tenancy continued as periodic before April 6, 2007, the deposit does not need to be protected. However, if a fixed-term tenancy that began before that date became a periodic tenancy after April 6, 2007, the landlord must protect the deposit and serve the tenant with information by June 23, 2015.

  • Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1171

    10:58 AM, 3rd December 2025, About 5 months ago

    Yes, my apologies. Having re-checked the rules, I agree that the requirement to protect the deposit by 2015 only applies to fixed terms ending after 6 April 2007.

  • Member Since April 2025 - Comments: 7

    12:38 PM, 4th December 2025, About 5 months ago

    Does he claim any benefits

    Advise him to make a claim

    I have raised it to the local authority housing allowance which you can Google on government or council site
    Which is close to the local renting rate here

    I have also told the tenants to expect a minimum of 2 % increase on top due to labour s tax rise

    You should have seen there faces especially as they voted Labour

    Regards geoff

Have Your Say

Every day, landlords who want to influence policy and share real-world experience add their voice here. Your perspective helps keep the debate balanced.

Not a member yet? Join In Seconds


Login with

or

Related Articles