1 week ago | 1 comments
Apparently, being a ‘greedy’ landlord now means hanging on to a rented house you’d prefer to sell because you’re worried about your tenants.
This is one of those funny details that gets left out whenever politicians talk about squeezing another few quid out of us.
A landlord friend of mine said something this week that made me sit up and think.
He owns three properties, has great tenants, though that wasn’t always the case, and is slowly coming to an alarming conclusion.
He said the returns just don’t justify the hassle or the risk anymore.
Yet he can’t bring himself to put them on the market and he doesn’t want to face the tenants should he decide to do so.
One reason for that is that he knows his tenants will have a nightmare finding somewhere else.
To me, this is a proper trap when staying in the game is getting harder to afford, yet cashing out feels like turfing out decent people who haven’t done anything wrong.
I’m willing to bet plenty of Property118 readers know this feeling only too well.
Then, this week saw the Intermediary Mortgage Lenders Association (IMLA) dropping some numbers that should wipe the smiles off smug ministers’ faces.
Take their example: a landlord on a £100,000 salary with a £250,000 property and a £150,000 mortgage.
Before tax, the annual profit on the rent is £4,365.
But once the Budget’s new income tax rate kicks in, IMLA reckons the effective tax rate hits roughly 124%.
If you’ve just frowned, you are right to do.
Labour thinks it’s acceptable that landlords pay more in tax than the actual profit.
I’m sure there are loads of landlords who have been stuck in this ridiculous hole for a while now.
Run IMLA’s rounded figure and the tax bill on that house comes to around £5,413.
That leaves the landlord having to find roughly £1,048 from somewhere else just to plug the gap.
Let’s call it what it is: subsidising your tenant’s rent out of your own pocket.
To be fair, that specific scenario involves losing the personal tax allowance.
Not every landlord gets hit at that exact rate, and pretending we all do just weakens our case.
Even so, IMLA calculates that a higher-rate taxpayer sitting below that threshold still faces an effective rate of about 74%.
Forget the worst-case scenario for a second and ask yourself a basic question: what’s actually left for the person putting up the capital, shouldered with the risk, and doing the legwork?
I appreciate that having a decent day job might mean you can stomach the loss, but it doesn’t make the business model any less broken.
Usually, someone pipes up and says, “Just stick it all in a limited company.”
If only it were that simple since restructuring drags in capital gains, refinancing headaches and hefty accountancy fees.
As Property118 regularly points out, incorporation is far from a silver bullet and doesn’t suit every landlord.
Selling up brings its own bill of costs and stress, too.
And through all of this, the tenant still needs a roof over their head.
You build real relationships over the years; that’s one that matters to both sides.
Worse still, IMLA’s numbers show that putting the rent up can actually leave everyone worse off.
The tenant takes a hit to their monthly budget, while the landlord barely sees a penny of it once extra costs and the taxman take their cut.
A tiny annual surplus won’t save you either because one broken boiler or a leaky roof wipes it out in an afternoon.
And that’s before you’ve even factored in a penny for your own time.
Nobody is asking for guaranteed profits, we all understand that every investment carries risk.
Ministers need to grasp the difference between taking a commercial gamble and having the goalposts moved every six months after your cash is already locked in.
The government also needs to stop treating a landlord’s decision to stick around as proof that the system works.
Some stay because selling is too expensive.
Others are just crossing their fingers and hoping the numbers eventually make sense again.
And some, like my mate, stay put because they genuinely care about their tenants.
That last bunch deserves far better than having their decency mistaken for an endless pot of free money.
Good tenants shouldn’t have to rely on their landlord’s willingness to absorb another financial kicking, and responsible landlords shouldn’t be forced to choose between their own bank balance and keeping a good tenancy alive.
A landlord’s conscience is not a housing policy. Shame on Labour for acting as if it should be.
Until next time,
The Landlord Crusader
17 comments on this article
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
Previous Article
Landlords aren’t working people, are they?
1 week ago | 1 comments
1 week ago
1 week ago | 7 comments
Member Since February 2020 - Comments: 415
10:15 AM, 13th November 2026, About 6 days ago
Its just vindictive, trying to push out the small landlord from the market to bring in bigger landlords that are easier to control.
Its false economy, I’ve gone down to a 3 day workweek, and as much as of my salary as I can goes into Salaray sacrifice.
So the increase in rental taxes have reduced other taxes.
It could be argued that my reduced workweek slack is picked up by other employees.
Yes, but in India.
Member Since September 2018 - Comments: 3820 - Articles: 5
10:58 AM, 13th November 2026, About 6 days ago
All this is a direct result of political interference in private business, it is a simply as that. With a socialist/communist gvt now in power, the ‘blame’ game in in full swing. Private landlords exploit, is their mantra and therefore they must be stopped.
They are pig headed and wont listen to tenants who are at the end of the chain and finding it more an more difficult to find accommodation. But the tide will turn. They need the votes of the very same people they are hurting to stay in power.
So its down to landlords to call this out and tell tenants what’s really happening.
There is a winter of discontent ahead, but we need people on the streets. France is up in arms, so is Spain, yet we do nothing here.
Member Since October 2023 - Comments: 276
11:28 AM, 13th November 2026, About 6 days ago
This is exactly the trap I was in. I wanted to retire, but had really good tenants, and I wanted them to find somewhere else, rather than me just kicking them out. It took them nearly 3 years to find somewhere. And even then, that was a fluke, as they had a friend whose mother died, and they offered to rent them their mothers house.
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 3458 - Articles: 83
3:02 PM, 13th November 2026, About 6 days ago
Correct,
You say it brilliantly & many of us are like that.
Not once has the Govt been to ask me/us nor my tenants what they would like.
And my remaining tenants are corkers.
Someone send Landlord Crusaders article to the MP’s & Govt please. Those who have time & live near MP’s offices & Westminster, print loads of flyers & leave em all over. Send Dozens to Acorn & the renters groups.
This is typical example of many of my houses left:
On many houses, I’m losing 7k pa EACH house.
I’ve got lots house value 240k, tenant paying £1000ishpm, 12k pa, I get after tax 7k.
In normal safe investment tracker, on average I’d get 14k pa with ZERO tax till I sold the investment. And then be just one off CGT tax 24%.
What can we do to keep tenant safe? Oh I see, threaten Landlord with £7000 fines for not uploading boiler certificate to new £65 a year database costing landlord dozens more hours a year-That should work shun’t it?
And now the extra 4% Tax. When will this Govt wake up.
Tenant above been there 25 years, I can’t carry on with these losses, difficult conversation with him soon-I’m selling.
And yes the regulation, we’ve done nothing wrong, me nor tenant signed up for these rules & now threats of £7000 fines from all over, every bit of admin now is £7000 fine for error. Can have no MOT & serious car accidents & get £300 fine.
Govt just doesn’t get it, many of us don’t want the houses.
Govt: Well why have u got the house Mick?
Mick: We only keeping em for the tenant, where they gonna go?
Govt: So you not doing it to make loads of money & rip tenants off?
Mick: No, I’m actually losing lots, 7k per house per tenant per year & you driving me to now ask tenant to go cause I’m losing anyway & now you want to fine me £7000 for forgetting to upload a gas certificate to database even though I’ve ACTUALLY got the certificate. New trumped up database that’s gonna’ take me another 40 hours to do all houses in small time frame you’ve gave us.
Govt: Oh, we thought u were all greedy, so we like to fine u to get some’at back.
Who in there Right Mind is going to dig up a Concrete Floor at the cost of £6000 to £8000 pounds . Put some insulation in and Save £38 per year
They have no policy in place whatsoever if the Landlady doesn’t want the house, only keeping it for the tenant, why on earth would they want to spend £10,000 on something they don’t want?
And if insisting must be done, or can’t rent out, then we make tenants homeless unfortunately. Why can’t the Govt see this?
Already losing 7k pa than if the house sale funds were invested elsewhere & you want us to lose another another 10k?
Someone please get someone in Govt to recognise there are hundreds of thousands of Landlady’s that don’t want their properties & are desperately waiting for the tenant to move so they can sell.
They not all 20 years old desperate to earn some income & have got 30 years to ride it out.
Member Since May 2019 - Comments: 19
4:03 PM, 13th November 2026, About 6 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Mick Roberts at 13/11/2026 – 15:02
Of course if you need to sell due to losses the tenants may not be able to leave if there’s nowhere to go. Then it’s down a long expensive road to get your property back.
Member Since June 2014 - Comments: 1575
6:02 PM, 13th November 2026, About 6 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Mick Roberts at 13/11/2026 – 15:02
“On many houses, I’m losing 7k pa EACH house.”
I agree with the sentiment Mick, I’m the same, but that’s not quite correct. You’ve not accounted for capital appreciation. Nottingham house prices have gone up what? Say 4% average pa. On a 240K house that’s £9600.
“When will this Govt wake up.”
When they get voted out. Hopefully the next lot will bring some sanity and fairness.
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 3458 - Articles: 83
3:32 PM, 14th November 2026, About 5 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Penny Lyon at 13/11/2026 – 16:03
I’m not losing as such. But put the 240k house funds into normal safe tracker & I’m 7k pa better off. So why would I lose 7k pa on that, & also be threatened with 7k & 30k fines & more hours doing Govt admin?
My tenants can’t get anywhere, hard for most on Benefits in Nottingham.
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 3458 - Articles: 83
3:32 PM, 14th November 2026, About 5 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Monty Bodkin at 13/11/2026 – 18:02
Yes Monty, you right. Capital appreciation will help eventually. But will we ever get the house back to get that Capital?
Will Capital appreciation happen much in next 5 years?
Yes I do recognise that some of these houses that has said tenants in have gone up in value 7k pa since tenant lived there. And tenant could argue I’ve helped you with that Mick.
I would say You din’t help me with the deposit on the house 25 years ago did u-Who paid that? Who’s done all the work? Who took the loss on the rent v’s mortgage/outgoings in the first 10 years?
Member Since August 2025 - Comments: 5
9:27 AM, 15th November 2026, About 4 days ago
Govt puts taxes on things that are bad, booze, cigarettes, pollution/cars etc; and reduces or eliminates on things that are essential – no VAT on food, and reduced on electric.
So increasing tax on landlords can only mean govt wants landlords to exit, and/or that housing is not essential.
Member Since January 2026 - Comments: 25
4:37 PM, 15th November 2026, About 4 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Penny Lyon at 13/11/2026 – 16:03
14 months to evict non paying/house wreckers
of 2 adults & 7 kids . It has cost me £30k++ to get it back and house withdrawn from market. The Govt couldn’t give a s… about Landlords issues and persecution of all Landlords ok. Tenants can do no wrong.