Can you mutually end an existing tenancy and sign a new one at higher rent?

Calendar showing a 12-month rent increase restriction and a question about starting a new tenancy.
12:01 AM, 18th November 2026, 19 hours ago 3

Hello, I would like some advice please. I have just done the rent increase through section 13, the rent increase took effect in October, but it’s still £150 below the market rent.

Now the tenant wants her son to move in with her for a year so, so can save his money, she is living alone.

I am not happy for this below market rent with two people.

They expected that I will increase the rent but I can’t due to the 12 months restriction, even they are happy to pay the market rent.

So can a landlord and tenant can mutually agree to end an existing tenancy and enter into a genuinely new tenancy at a different rent with same tenant?

Does this reset the 12 month timetable for the rent increase restriction?

Thanks,
Wanda


Share This Article

  • Member Since February 2011 - Comments: 3463 - Articles: 286

    10:03 AM, 18th November 2026, About 9 hours ago

    Wanda, assuming this is an assured tenancy in England, yes, in principle, but only through a genuine, voluntary surrender of the existing tenancy and grant of a new one. Shelter’s current legal guidance expressly recognises that landlord and tenant can agree a new tenancy at a different rent without a section 13 notice.

    Simply agreeing to pay more under the existing tenancy is not sufficient. Her son moving in does not override the annual restriction following October’s increase.

    A genuinely new tenancy would start a fresh 52-week period before a further section 13 increase could take effect. However, the tenant could challenge an above-market starting rent through the tribunal within the first six months.

    Do not assume that signing replacement paperwork alone achieves this. Have a housing solicitor check the existing agreement and properly document any surrender and new tenancy, including whether her son would be a permitted occupier or joint tenant.

  • Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1431

    11:01 AM, 18th November 2026, About 8 hours ago

    Yes you can. You need to:
    1. draft a new tenancy agreement and other paperwork
    2. Do an end of tenancy inspection
    3. Refund the deposit less any agreed damages
    4. Do a new inventory
    5. jointly sign a deed of surrender with a witness
    6. Take a new deposit and months rent in advance
    7. All sign the new tenancy and other paperwork
    8. Lodge the new deposit with a deposit scheme

    Don’t leave any significant time between 5 and 7.

  • Member Since September 2026 - Comments: 62

    12:50 PM, 18th November 2026, About 6 hours ago

    Hi Wanda,

    Neil’s covered the surrender and regrant itself, so one correction to DPT’s list before you work through it, because step 6 is now a trap.

    Since 1 May 2026, paragraph 1(1A) of Schedule 1 to the Tenant Fees Act 2019 makes a payment of rent a prohibited payment if it is payable before the tenancy is entered into and the tenancy is an assured tenancy. Section 5A goes further: a landlord must not invite or encourage that payment, and must not accept it even if the tenant offers. So the first month’s rent on the new tenancy has to fall due after everyone has signed, not as part of the handover. The penalty under section 8 runs to £5,000.

    The other thing I’d settle before anything is drafted is how her son goes on the paperwork. If he’s a joint tenant on a periodic tenancy, his notice to quit ends the tenancy for both of them (Hammersmith v Monk), so when he moves out next year your tenant’s home goes with him. As a permitted occupier he can’t do that, and your new rent still reflects two people living there.

    And serve fresh prescribed information on the new deposit within 30 days. It’s a new tenancy, so the old certificate doesn’t carry over.

    OJ
    Am I a Legal Landlord


Related Articles