£2.5 million in property equity, yet £30,000 a year short of living costs
This is a case study of a 72-year-old landlord who had built substantial wealth, but was using his savings to pay for everyday life and could not afford the inheritance tax planning he wanted. A conversation with his children added another reason to reconsider his property portfolio.
I want to share a real client story because I suspect quite a few landlords will recognise something of themselves in it. I will keep his identity confidential, but the circumstances are worth explaining.
He first came to Property118 after reading an article about an investment outside property on which I was receiving a 10% fixed return. He had £300,000 in the bank, so he contacted the people who had arranged the investment for me, obtained the information and went away to consider it. He did not proceed.
Some time later, he read another of our articles, this time asking the question “Could your family afford to keep your property portfolio after you die?” This resulted in him obtaining a quotation for Whole of Life insurance written into trust to provide the money to pay inheritance tax. He was just over 70, in good health, and concerned about an estimated £1.5 million inheritance tax bill. The quotation he obtained was approximately £3,000 a month, or £36,000 a year. Again, he went away to think about it.
It was only when he subsequently booked a Property118 consultation that the reasons for his hesitation became clear.
He explained that he had approximately £2.5 million of equity in his rental portfolio, after deducting the mortgages. It was producing nearly £90,000 a year before tax, but the amount he was left with after tax was only about £30,000. His living costs were £60,000 a year.
The Section 24 restrictions on finance cost relief were only part of his predicament. As many landlords know only too well, mortgage interest is no longer deducted when calculating taxable residential rental profits for affected individuals. A restricted basic-rate tax reduction takes its place, which can leave a considerable gap between the profit you actually make and the income on which tax is calculated.
That £300,000 in the bank now takes on a rather different significance. He was £30,000 a year short of what he needed to live on. In his mind, the savings would cover that shortfall for another ten years, assuming his income and spending stayed much the same. Of course, living longer, inflation or an unexpected expense could change that calculation.
You might reasonably think that a 10% return on £300,000 would produce the missing £30,000. He had considered that too. However, the return would be taxable, and he was worried about how much he would actually receive after tax. He also needed access to the capital. Committing the money he relied upon for everyday living was a very different proposition from investing spare cash.
Meanwhile, the inheritance tax concern went well beyond the rental portfolio. There was a valuable main home, a holiday home and other assets, as well as a pension fund to consider in the wider planning. Most unused pension funds and pension death benefits will come into the inheritance tax calculation for deaths from 6 April 2027, so the timing and the particular pension arrangements matter too.
He wanted to protect his children from a substantial tax bill, but the £36,000 annual insurance premium was more than the entire £30,000 he was retaining from his rental business. He was already using his savings to support himself. He felt asset-rich, cash-poor, and was beginning to feel that he had somehow failed. The Whole of Life premium was due to him being in his 70’s, and still in good health.
I can understand why he felt trapped. He had accumulated substantial wealth, yet neither of the opportunities he had investigated seemed affordable when considered against his existing income.
Our consultant drew his attention to what the £2.5 million tied up in the rental portfolio was actually producing. Nearly £90,000 before tax represented an income return on equity of approximately 3.6%. The £30,000 he retained was just 1.2%. Capital growth might add to his wealth, but it would not pay the bills unless he found a way to release it.
That opened up the possibility of selling the rental properties, even allowing for the capital gains tax. For the purposes of the discussion, suppose he was left with £1.5 million after repaying the mortgages, allowing for any discounts needed to sell, and paying the selling costs and CGT. Add the £300,000 already in the bank and he would have £1.8 million to work with.
At an illustrative 10% annual cash return, £1.8 million would produce £180,000 a year before tax. To give that some context, a UK individual receiving £180,000 solely as taxable interest, with no other income, would retain roughly £114,000 under 2026/27 tax rules, including the applicable savings starting rate. That would cover £60,000 of living costs and £36,000 of insurance premiums, with about £18,000 remaining.
Those figures explain why the possibility was worth exploring. He would need an FCA-authorised adviser to assess suitable investments and insurance, and to test whether the plan remained affordable with lower returns, fees and rising living costs.
Then there was the conversation with his children, which I think is a particularly important part of this story. They told him they did not want to inherit the rental portfolio anyway.
They considered the return diabolical given the risks their father faced and the increasing burden of legislation. They did not want to have to deal with probate involving an illiquid rental portfolio, the mortgages, or the pressure that could put them under. They much preferred the prospect of him releasing the equity and arranging his affairs so there would be money available to pay the inheritance tax.
In their minds, within a year of his death they could have the tax dealt with and be enjoying the benefit of what remained of his estate. That was their expectation, rather than a timetable anyone could guarantee. The tax itself normally falls due by the end of the sixth month after death, so the funding would need to be available earlier.
A suitable Whole of Life policy in trust could provide that money without waiting for probate, subject to the policy terms and premiums being maintained. The purpose would be to fund the bill, and the amount of cover needed would have to be reviewed after any sales. His home, holiday home and the rest of the estate would still need administering, but the children would be spared taking on a rental business they had already said they did not want.
There is still detailed work to do before an option discussed in a consultation becomes a plan someone can act upon. Actual sale proceeds, tax and suitable investments all need checking, and selling part of the portfolio or reducing borrowing may also be worth considering. The client remains the person who decides what he wants to do.
For me, the point is that a large capital gains tax bill should be weighed against what the money left afterwards could achieve. If retaining the properties means continuing to use up savings, struggling to fund family protection and ultimately leaving the children a business they do not want, the cost of selling deserves to be considered in that wider context.
He had built considerable wealth. It was entirely reasonable to look again at how that wealth could support his own life and benefit his family. I think many landlords would find that a useful conversation to have, particularly with their children.
If this sounds familiar, you can arrange a Property118 consultation to discuss your circumstances and the options to explore. It helps to start with what you need to live on, what you own, what you owe, your taxable income, and then what you want to retain and what your family would actually like to inherit.
BOOK YOUR CONSULTATION TODAY
66 comments on this article
Learn from your peers’ experience
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
Member Since January 2025 - Comments: 35
9:26 AM, 9th November 2026, About 1 week ago
Passing on property these days is passing on a burden, financial and administrative. If the children are not interested, then sell off. Your client in this case has had income for many years from his portfolio and now may be the time for him to divest himself and his children of the job of managing or selling the portfolio at his eventual demise.
The many new rules and costs have reduced profit to a point where many smaller landlords are in jeopardy. It’s a bad market to sell in, but it’s something that has to be weighed up.
Member Since March 2023 - Comments: 1533
9:29 AM, 9th November 2026, About 1 week ago
Reply to the comment left by GH at 09/11/2026 – 09:26
I agree, I currently have 5 proeprties which I will not sell until the tenants have moved out BUT my wife and both kids have said that as soon as I croak it the tenants will get their marching orders and they will sell
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 844 - Articles: 1
10:07 AM, 12th November 2026, About 5 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Mark Alexander – Founder of Property118 at 17:31
yes they crossed and sorry for delay due to moving house. thanks for explaining about future growth.
all of that is agreed, but they are different issues to what my observation concerned. my comments were more a viewpoint rather than a question – that IMO such a case study should have included a discussion on incorporation. and I suggested that once incorporated the properties could be sold possibly without incurring punitive taxes, so achieving the desired objectives, i.e.:
Reply to the comment left by Mark Alexander – Founder of Property118at 06/11/2026 – 08:36
‘I thought incorporation if appropriate would avoid SDLT and CGT, albeit hmrc can challenge. It would also avoid the latest income tax rises and allow mortgage costs to be offset?
properties could then be sold without CGT and funds either withdrawn or bequeathed to heirs. and I thought I read previously in promo that there were legacy benefits too by incorporating?’
one of your replies was something like this wasnt appropriate in this case which is fine but nevertheless I still think it the case study should have gone into this. to me imo this should have been part of the case study espec. when you have replied:
‘Incorporation is definitely an excellent option in the right circumstances.’
the above are the same points I have made previously.
Member Since January 2011 - Comments: 12306 - Articles: 1503
10:11 AM, 12th November 2026, About 5 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Joe Bloggs at 12/11/2026 – 10:07
I understand your point of view. Mine was to make a clear point without going into all of the details of the case and explaining the reasons for dismissing all the various options.
It was never intended to be an operating manual.
If you still disagree, let’s agree to disagree on this one.
Member Since June 2013 - Comments: 844 - Articles: 1
10:18 AM, 12th November 2026, About 5 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Mark Alexander – Founder of Property118 at 12/11/2026 – 10:11
of course. everyone can/ should have a view especially on a forum.
Member Since May 2018 - Comments: 2708
4:56 PM, 13th November 2026, About 3 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Ian Dimarian at 05/11/2026 – 12:25
I can’t be the only landlord being bombarded with adverts for other ideas over how to invest my money via sections of the UK media sponsored by financial services companies. I just received this paragraph which is entitled “Consider offshore investment bonds”. It says that it is the copyright of the I paper so I’m just quoting and if you need the source article you can search for it there.
Directly quoting what I just got targeted with it says. “If you sold multiple rental homes, you may have maxed out your annual Isa and pension allowances so offshore investment bonds could be an option. Commonly based in the Isle of Man or Ireland, these bonds let you hold investments without paying UK tax on the growth each year, but tax is typically paid when you take the profits out. Hallam said: “The tax comes when you take the money out, so the real question is how you’ll do that. Deferring tax is useful, but it’s not the end goal. You need to be able to spend and enjoy the money without creating an unnecessary tax bill.” Spinks added: “The charges and tax rules around withdrawals are complex, so specialist advice is essential.”
Now if you stop and think about that for a moment, reflect on the fact that Rachel Reeves increased tax on rental income, John Healey just did it again, Rachel Reeves’ tax changes attacking UK pensions kick in in spring 2027, UK based land and property is subject to UK inheritance tax but you might be able to avoid IHT by investing elsewhere. Notice that the financial services industry is waking up to the fact that landlords divesting their properties need somewhere else to put their cash and are promoting “offshore investment funds.”
Once you’ve considered that and had a chance to really think about it, how does it help to build 1.5 million new homes, keep rents at affordable levels, house tenants from all walks of life, or help to grow the UK economy, if the UK government creates a fiscal environment where it makes more sense to invest your money offshore? In offshore investment bonds? Not bricks, mortar and tiles?
How does that put a roof over anybody’s head?