Punished for playing fair: how the Renters’ Rights Act quietly voided perfectly valid Section 21s
If you gave your tenant a full 12-month tenancy from September 2025 and served a proper Section 21 before 1 May, you did everything right. The government made sure it counted for nothing.
Let me describe how a great many landlords got wronged by the government acting flagrantly illegally in the last year – which not a single journalist picked up on. One actual example of many similar cases. The decent, careful landlord, who never in two decades of working hard for tenants ever had to ask a tenant to leave. But now, he had to sell his own home, move into a tenanted property to be able to pay for private school fees, having lost his job.
In summer 2025 he let a property on a standard 12-month AST: 1 September 2025 to 1 September 2026. The academic year, the school year – the way a huge slice of the market has always let. No six-month break clause, because he wanted to give his tenant proper security.
He read the guidance, and before the 30 April 2026 cut-off he served a valid Section 21. Correct form, deposit protected, EPC, gas safety, How to Rent guide – the lot. Possession date: 1 September 2026, the end of the fixed term and the earliest date the law allowed.
That notice was dead the moment he served it. He just didn’t know it yet.
The trap
Under the transitional rules issued AFTER MAY, a pre-1 May Section 21 was decreed by this government to only could be used if court proceedings were issued by the earlier of six months from service or 31 July 2026. Miss that and the notice lapses. No discretion, no extension, no revival.
But …. you cannot issue a Section 21 claim until the notice has expired, and a Section 21 cannot expire before the fixed term ends. A fixed term ending on 1 September cannot produce a claim by 31 July. It is arithmetically impossible – and the government’s own guidance confirms that where the earliest date proceedings could start fell on or after 1 August 2026, the notice cannot be used at all.
So every landlord whose fixed term ran past July – every September-to-September let, every academic-year let, every full year given without a break clause – was allowed to serve a valid notice that could never be enforced.
Meanwhile, the tough landlord down the road who had not given a fixed 12-month tenancy but instead a rolling periodic tenancy served two months’ notice in April and issued in July. Same law, same deadline, opposite result. The deciding factor was how much security you had given your tenant. The more generous you were, the harder you were hit. As in most cases in the UK – a good deed never goes unpunished.
What it actually costs
When the notice lapsed on 31 July, the tenancy converted to an assured periodic tenancy. To get the property back you now need a Section 8 ground – usually Ground 1 (moving in) or Ground 1A (selling) – with four months’ notice, then court if the tenant stays put. Possession slides from September 2026 into spring 2027 or beyond.
That is six to nine months of a property you planned to live in, sell or refurbish, still occupied. Sales fall through. Family moves go on hold. Mortgage and running costs keep ticking. And if a Ground 1A sale fails, you are barred from re-letting for 12 months. And the landlord is left with great uncertainty and extra costs – because even when the notice to vacate lapses, the tenant can just calmly, with arms folded, stay in the property and the landlord has to go to court to request possession, which can cost a year or more.
This was entirely avoidable
The fix was one sentence: where a valid Section 21 was served on a fixed-term AST before 1 May, allow proceedings within three months of the fixed term ending. It would only have helped notices that were valid, served in time, and that the landlord was legally barred from using earlier. Nobody could have called that a loophole.
Instead, the drafting treated a landlord who honoured a 12-month commitment exactly like one who never bothered to serve at all. Either nobody in the department thought about September lets, or somebody did know and think and decided decent landlords were acceptable collateral. I’m not sure which is worse.
Do please write to your MP. The Act was sold as fairness. Ask whether punishing the landlords who gave tenants the most security is what fairness looks like. The Act has a great many flaws, so that the opposite of what was aimed at, happier tenants, has been achieved.
Were your Section 21s voided the same way? Tell us in the comments – the more cases on record, the harder this is to ignore.
By Accommodation Provider
1 comment on this article
Learn from your peers’ experience
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
Previous Article
Section 13 proposed rent grey area?
Member Since March 2023 - Comments: 5
12:00 PM, 16th November 2026, About 6 minutes ago
Yes, I got caught by this trap and I now having to go the slow and expensive route to obtain possession to sell the property.