Issues with my fire risk assessor?

Issues with my fire risk assessor?

Fire risk assessment warning showing detached smoke alarm, fire extinguisher and communal hallway in a converted two-flat property.
12:01 AM, 16th July 2026, 3 weeks ago 3

Hello, I commissioned a London-based fire risk assessor to undertake an assessment of the communal area of my terraced property in North London.

There are 2 self contained flats. The ground floor has 2 bedrooms, and the first floor has 3 bedrooms which includes a loft conversion.

The ground floor tenants were out when he arrived despite me informing them, so he proceeded to inspect the first floor. After viewing the first floor, he then forgot to look inside the ground floor flat and sent me a report having only looked inside the first floor flat.

There were several issues:

  1. He classified my property as an “additional HMO” which could have led to my receiving a criminal conviction
  2. He went far beyond the remit of a fire assessment of the communal areas and suggested that we could no longer use one of the bedrooms in the first floor unless a “mist” was installed. I suppose this is similar to some kind of water sprinkler system as we had a gas cooker and not an electric cooker
  3. The report stated that I did not have a Gas Safety certificate and an up-to-date electrical inspection report when I had
  4. He took a week to send the bogus report, and the following day sent me a letter giving prices to do various jobs such as a door survey when my property is not an HMO
  5. He failed to report that we had emergency lighting and smoke alarms in the 2 communal hallways that were hard wired in addition to smoke alarms on all levels of the properties
  6. I had a meeting and challenged him on these and other issues. He said he would refund my £295 and stated that the report was now void.

I engaged another professional who charged me £150 and gave me a clean report with no issues.

I’d like to urge all landlords to be on your guard when appointing a fire risk assessor and be wary when the assessment means engaging them to do additional work.

Thank you.


Share This Article

Comments

  • Member Since March 2024 - Comments: 305

    10:14 AM, 16th July 2026, About 3 weeks ago

    All in all, not too dissimilar incompetence to the inspection done by City of York council on one of my HMOs when they brought in additional licensing.

  • Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1293

    4:34 PM, 16th July 2026, About 3 weeks ago

    It may well be an HMO. Unless there is full separation of the 2 flats, its effectively one household and could be an Additional HMO. If there is full separation, it may be a s257 HMO. You should look into this further.

  • Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 208

    10:20 PM, 16th July 2026, About 3 weeks ago

    I agree with DPT. If your building was converted to flats prior to 1991 it is a section 257 HMO, and may be subject to Additional licencing. If there is Additional licencing in that area, you need to check if section 257 buildings are in scope – that varies council to council.

Have Your Say

Every day, landlords who want to influence policy and share real-world experience add their voice here. Your perspective helps keep the debate balanced.

Not a member yet? Join In Seconds


Login with

or

Related Articles