Help - Tenant not moving out and claiming extreme hardship!

Help – Tenant not moving out and claiming extreme hardship!

A women at a laptop in a kitchen with her hands on her head in frustration
12:01 AM, 12th September 2023, 3 years ago 39

Hello, I moved from Kent to another part of the country for my son’s education and I rented out my house to a family with 3 kids. It didn’t work out for my son’s school and we wanted to come back to our home, but the tenant didn’t want to move out.

We had to find alternative accommodation from December 2022. I served Section 21 to the tenant in January to move out at the end of March, but he didn’t. Since then he stopped paying rent. We asked the court for a possession order in April, but the tenant put up a very dramatic defence claiming extreme hardship. The case was heard outside the court and the judge awarded him another 6 months to stay at the property due to some specific wording he found in our contract (our lawyer said that shouldn’t be the case!). We have been advised by the lawyer to reissue s21, which we did and we also served him with s8 for unpaid rent (now 6 months unpaid) and we have a hearing on 25th September.

Most likely our tenant will be using all sorts of tricks to get away from paying, using extreme hardship. Some time ago the tenant offered to buy our house, therefore he must have money! Recently, we also discovered he already has 3 CCJs on his name.

Please advise how can I deal with that kind of tenant to get out to have our home back quicker. How can we believe the law system will be on our side with the tenant claiming extreme hardship? We have to pay the mortgage and rent while waiting for him to move out!!!

Thanks,

J0


Share This Article

Comments

  • Member Since August 2019 - Comments: 22

    9:56 AM, 16th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    What a horrible situation for you and the tenant, I hope you find a solution soon, I have no advice. On the face of it this shows how hard it has become to be a LL. Over the last 45 years I have let my main home on a few occasions while working abroad. The tenants knew I’d be returning eventually and we parted on good terms. These days I’d not be prepared to rent out my home while I was away for fear of finding I couldn’t move back again without this sort of nightmare scenario. If ‘accidental’ LLs can’t get their property back, particularly if the tenant stops paying rent, it’ll result in homes that could be available being left empty, further depleting supply. As well as letting my main home while away, I have also had ‘BTL’ properties and, fair enough, that is different, it’s set up as a way to generate an income, but I have still wanted my property back eventually so I could renovate/develop and sell it. I have great sympathy for the affected tenants, particularly if the LL decides to evict really quickly, like at at end of the first 6 months as the tenant will have had costs and put in a lot of effort, that’s very stressful and as a LL I’d be happy with the option of longer minimum tenancies. However, it seems that the risks facing huge numbers of ‘small landlords’ and ‘accidental’ landlords are too great to be worth it now, presumably what the government intends. But, nobody wins.

  • Member Since March 2023 - Comments: 51

    10:41 AM, 16th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Where rent is unpaid regularly serve rental statement detailing rent owed and the mounting interest on the rent that he now owes you.
    Go the section 8 route and make sure your grounds include ALL legal grounds
    ie you want to move back into the property
    rent arrears over two months AND
    habitual non payment /late payment of.rent
    the second means he can’t escape eviction by paying it all off just before the case

    Make clear you will pursue in full back rent , interest owed on it , all and legal fees incurred.

    And for the future always do referencing that checks for CCJ’s and ask the tenant to sign a piece of paper saying they don’t have CJ’s outstanding debts etc . That piece of paper could be very useful if you later find out they were dishonest.

  • Member Since May 2018 - Comments: 1999

    11:22 AM, 16th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Reply to the comment left by Jan at 16/09/2023 – 09:56
    If I could agree with this statement more than 100% I would do it.

    In this case as I understand the situation from the limited facts available the property is the owner’s principle private residence and the owner is having to find alternative accommodation whilst continuing to pay a non-buy-to-let mortgage because the (Squatter?) is refusing to move out.

    At the end though the only way that we would be able to judge the rights and wrongs of this is if we knew what the “the specific wording he [the judge] found in our contract” was.

  • Member Since October 2022 - Comments: 85

    10:59 PM, 17th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Reply to the comment left by Happy housing at 12/09/2023 – 10:15
    Have to agree. The courts are beyond incompetent; some might say corrupt. Judges appear to be politically left-leaning. It says something when landlords are better off paying feckless tenants to leave instead of using the courts. But the supposed just and fair court system no longer exists.

  • Member Since May 2023 - Comments: 206

    5:12 AM, 18th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Reply to the comment left by TJP at 17/09/2023 – 22:59
    So what happens to a hb tenant if you do not renew the agreement? Do all there benefits stop?

  • Member Since April 2023 - Comments: 16

    11:31 AM, 18th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Reply to the comment left by Happy housing at 18/09/2023 – 05:12
    I wondered about that myself. I lknow for a fact that HB is separate from all other benefits a tenant may get, so they wouldn’t be affected. Its entirely up to the tenant as to whether the HB is applied to the rent, and will only show up in the regular reviews and confirmations of income requested by the Housing Dept. For that reason, I can’t think that the Council would ever advise not to pay the rent – but that’s not the same as advising to “stay put” at the expiry of Notice to Quit.

  • Member Since May 2023 - Comments: 206

    11:33 AM, 18th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    No but UC ask tenant for tenancy renewal every year.

  • Member Since April 2023 - Comments: 16

    11:48 AM, 18th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Reply to the comment left by Happy housing at 18/09/2023 – 11:33
    But the tenancy hasn’t been renewed in cases like this – it’s still on the same terms as the original, but now on a rolling periodic basis (or something). The tenant won’t leave, but the rent is still due regardless (same as council tax, utility bills etc).

  • Member Since May 2023 - Comments: 206

    11:51 AM, 18th September 2023, About 3 years ago

    Yes but my question is If a landlord does not renew a UC tenancy agreement, and there asking tenant for a renewal contract which they do. What happens in this situation? Does all the UC payments stop for Tenant?

Have Your Say

Every day, landlords who want to influence policy and share real-world experience add their voice here. Your perspective helps keep the debate balanced.

Not a member yet? Join In Seconds


Login with

or

Related Articles