Section 13 proposed rent grey area?

Section 13 rent increase notice beside a rental property under storm clouds and a large question mark
12:02 AM, 16th November 2026, 12 hours ago 1

Although this is via an AI response, if reasonably accurate, it states that there is a strict legal expectation that your proposed annual rent increase aligns with the local market rate.

Although that is determined by the First-tier Tribunal ( Property Chamber), it appears to require you to adhere to this at the application stage, even when you are confidently expecting your tenant to approve such an increase. Google it yourselves.

The AI says: For example, you might sit down with your tenant prior to completing the S13, and explain the many additional burdens and costs imposed during the previous twelve months, and reach an agreement that rent will need to increase by, say 10%. You then research what is locally being achieved, not advertised, to find that it’s, say 5% less than you’re already receiving, and that the property economics then become unviable.

You might have the property locally in the best condition, best EPC, least anti-social environment, long-term tenants, etc., but is it prescribed that you should apparently adhere to the current local rate?

Obviously, you can propose whatever you wish on the form, but if, further down the line, you are using Form 3A for a possession claim for example, say based on arrears, could a rental increase not having conformed to local market rate come into the equation for not having complied, even though it wasn’t challenged at the time?

Thanks,

Andrew


Share This Article

  • Member Since September 2026 - Comments: 55

    10:51 AM, 16th November 2026, About 1 hour ago

    Hi Andrew,

    Worth splitting that in two, because the Act answers the halves differently.

    On the notice itself there’s no market test at all. Section 13(2) lets you serve a notice in the prescribed form “proposing a new rent”, and it doesn’t have to track locally achieved rents. The open market question lives in section 14, and it only engages if your tenant applies to the tribunal, which they’d have to do, under section 13(4), before the beginning of the new period you specified.

    The real asymmetry is section 14ZB(5), in force 1 May 2026. The tribunal’s figure is the open market rent if that’s lower than your proposed rent, and otherwise your proposed rent. So it can’t award more than you asked for. There’s no floor at what the tenant pays now either, so an over pitched notice invites a cut rather than a smaller rise.

    On the Form 3A worry, I’d relax. An unchallenged section 13 increase is just the rent under the tenancy, whatever local comparables say. Your own example is where you’re exposed. Since section 13(5) was omitted on 1 May, section 13(4A) makes an informally agreed uplift “of no effect”, so that 10% never became lawfully due. An agreement under 13(4)(b) can only go lower than the notice. That’s the position in England.

    OJ
    Am I a Legal Landlord