3 weeks ago
Making Tax Digital has cost taxpayers more than £1bn and is now more than £800m over budget.
A report by The Telegraph reveals that the scheme cost HMRC an additional £142m in 2025-26.
Making Tax Digital for Income Tax became compulsory in April 2026 for landlords and sole traders with qualifying income of more than £50,000.
The threshold will fall to more than £30,000 from April 2027, bringing a further group of landlords, property owners and self-employed people into the system.
According to The Telegraph, 2025-26 is the scheme’s second most expensive year to date, taking the total cost of the troubled rollout to £1.03bn.
However, the programme has faced repeated delays, revisions and technical issues, pushing costs more than £800m above its original budget.
However, HMRC continues to insist that Making Tax Digital reduces the administrative burden for landlords and businesses.
An HMRC spokesman told The Telegraph: “Making Tax Digital modernises our systems and will raise billions of pounds for public services, as well as reducing the admin burden of paying tax for many businesses.”
As previously reported by Property118, despite the government claiming Making Tax Digital will help landlords, an accountant says this is not the case.
Simon Misiewicz previously told Property118: “There’s no real benefit beyond maybe streamlining some of the work you already do, does it help with tax returns and submissions? The truth is, I can’t see how.
“There’s no advantage for the individual in submitting quarterly returns, because HMRC doesn’t do anything with them until the end of the year. You don’t pay your taxes any earlier, and there is no real cash-flow benefit for the government”.
The government admitted in the Making Tax Digital impact assessment that landlords earning £50,000 could incur an average transitional cost of £285 and an average annual additional cost of £115.
27 comments on this article
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
Previous Article
Shelter names new interim chief executiveNext Article
Flats dominate London homes available to let
3 weeks ago
1 month ago | 2 comments
1 month ago | 18 comments
Member Since October 2022 - Comments: 90
8:49 AM, 17th November 2026, About 2 days ago
Reply to the comment left by Sally Robinson at 17/11/2026 – 08:39
They’re definitely expecting a return on their MTD investment and they do not care if small business have to spend endless amounts of time and money complying. Big Brother, soviet style has arrived
Member Since May 2018 - Comments: 2718
12:19 PM, 17th November 2026, About 2 days ago
Reply to the comment left by TJP at 17/11/2026 – 08:49
90% of employment in the United Kingdom is in small businesses and that is where the growth in employment came from after the 2008 financial crash. The small businesses come from the micro-businesses, many of whom start out as self-employed. In the 1970s John Healey’s namesake Denis Healey famously drove many of the UK’s high-earners offshore. Today, even a small business can offshore part of its activities, you don’t have to be a rock star or film star. I run a small business and coincidentally today I received an email (as a small business) offering me the chance to employ people from outside the UK. As so many people work online they can now work from home and home might not be the UK. In fact, I already know people running UK businesses who live in France, or on the Iberian peninsula and there is nothing to stop a small UK-based business from employing people from outside the UK to keep the wage-bill down (including the national insurance bill) rather than to employ UK-based employees or self-employed people.
Only a bunch of idiots would be implementing Making Tax Digital and making it difficult to be a self-employed person in the United Kingdom, especially with the rise in adoption of AI technologies.
Member Since February 2024 - Comments: 127
7:55 AM, 18th November 2026, About 1 day ago
Reply to the comment left by Beaver at 12:19
As someone who may be be leaving the UK next calendar year , for good, I found your comment very illunminating and interesting. I think only the intelligent and flexble will be able to survive and nuture their offspring , their legacies, to the maximum.
I have a great letting agent, I have sold off the cheaper properties not worth upgrading to an EPC of C or more and also avoiding most of the ‘benefits claimants’ as tenants. And I will be safer.
Member Since May 2018 - Comments: 2718
11:18 AM, 18th November 2026, About 1 day ago
Reply to the comment left by Sally Robinson at 18/11/2026 – 07:55
Unfortunately, both experience and intelligence are sadly lacking in our present labour government. British Land is planning to use AI to cut the size of its workforce:
https://www.cityam.com/ftse-100-landowner-cuts-jobs-and-embraces-ai/
Worldwide, companies are looking to AI to gain competitive efficiencies and streamline their workforces:
https://www.reuters.com/business/world-at-work/companies-cutting-jobs-investments-shift-toward-ai-2026-10-22/
Many mid-level white-collar jobs or tasks can be done by AI in big companies and of course there is still the potential for a small business to use both off-shore services or AI to reduce their own costs and liabilities imposed upon them by labour because AI-driven tools are available to small businesses and remote working can mean from outside the UK.
What makes our labour government incompetent is that collectively they both have almost no experience of business and also are too arrogant to listen to anybody else; what makes them stupid is that they pursue the same kinds of policies that Denis Healey and Gordon Brown pursued and think (in their glee at getting into government in a majority) that they’ll get a different result from Denis Healey or Gordon Brown…”…because it’s us doing it.”
But what makes our present labour government exceptionally stupid is not realising that if you make it more difficult, expensive and risky to employ people (as this labour government has done) and you simultaneously make it more difficult to be self-employed at a time when AI is likely to cause a bonfire of white-collar jobs then you are going to turn a fiscal hole into a disaster. Labour don’t have any new ideas…they say one thing but do something else. They talk a big story but they still behave as though it’s 1947 or 1976. The union lackeys they put into government still behave as though most employees work for British Rail, the Coal Board or the National Health Service; but 90% of employment is in small business. That’s also where the growth is, unless you are stupid and stifle that growth because you have no idea of what you are doing.
MTD isn’t good for reducing unemployment, good for reducing the benefits bill or good for providing a diverse and responsive housing market. Labour should be listening to small landlords and also listening to the small business community. What labour are doing is undermining growth in the economy….it is vandalism.
Member Since May 2018 - Comments: 2718
2:26 PM, 18th November 2026, About 1 day ago
Reply to the comment left by Beaver at 18/11/2026 – 11:18
And to make things even worse, GBNews just reported the latest figures from the Office of National Statistics as saying that Britain now has more economically inactive migrants than the entire population of Birmingham:
https://www.gbnews.com/politics/migrant-crisis-labour-rise-foreign-nationals-claiming-benefits
They say “…the number of working-aged people born overseas who are not in employment and have not been seeking work within the last four weeks reached 1.27 million in September 2026……….European Union citizens made up the largest share of overseas claimants, accounting for roughly half of all migrants drawing Britain’s primary welfare payment.”
Against this economic backdrop why would you make it more expensive, difficult and risky as an employer to employ people and why would you make it more difficult to be self-employed than for example to claim Universal Credit? And with all those people also needing to be housed why would you make it more difficult and risky for small landlords to house people?
Surely you’d only do it if you were a bunch of idiots.
Member Since May 2017 - Comments: 865
2:48 PM, 18th November 2026, About 1 day ago
Reply to the comment left by Beaver at 18/11/2026 – 14:26
In the middle East they say if you want to work go to the US, if you want to live on benefits go to Europe
Member Since May 2018 - Comments: 2718
2:55 PM, 18th November 2026, About 1 day ago
Reply to the comment left by JB at 18/11/2026 – 14:48
If you want to live on benefits go to Europe…but the EU will be happy for you to go to the UK to claim Universal Credit because it saves them going to the trouble of sending you to Rwanda.
In the midst of the madness please don’t miss that partnerships aren’t obliged to submit via MTD. Here’s an AI summary:
Current Status for Partnerships
HMRC has confirmed that partnerships—including general partnerships, limited partnerships, and limited liability partnerships (LLPs)—are not currently mandated to follow MTD for Income Tax. There is no set start date for when partnerships will need to comply, and the phased rollout of MTD for Income Tax explicitly excluded partnerships from all mandation phases.
The deferral is due to the complexity of partnership structures, profit-sharing arrangements, and the interaction between partnership returns and individual partner returns
Individual Partner Considerations
While the partnership itself is deferred, individual partners may still need to comply with MTD if they have other qualifying income, such as from a sole trade or rental property. However, a partner’s share of profit from the partnership does not count towards their qualifying income for MTD purposes, meaning they do not need to keep digital records or submit quarterly updates for this income
Partners must still include their share of profits in their annual Self Assessment tax return using compatible software.