Judges block eviction that mars a tenant’s human rights

Judges block eviction that mars a tenant’s human rights

14:07 PM, 24th February 2011, About 11 years ago 11

Text Size

The latest Supreme Court case in to tenant rights may mean landlords may not be able to evict tenants who run up rent arrears or behave badly to neighbours.

The court ruled eviction can breach a tenant’s human rights – and denied Hounslow Council the permission to throw out tenant Rebecca Powell despite her owing £3,500 in rent arrears on her council home.

Landlords and lawyers are concerned that tenants will now try and shield deliberate non-payment of rents behind human rights laws.

At this stage, the only cases testing the European Convention on Human Rights relating to the right to ‘respect for a person’s home’ involve tenants in social housing.

The same human rights thinking could also be applied to private tenants – especially those in rent arrears while receiving local housing benefit.

Delivering judgement, Lord Hope said the ‘time had come to accept and apply the jurisprudence of the European court’.

Miss Powell, 23, was given a council home in Cranford, West London, in April 2007.  Around 14 months later, Miss Powell, who lives with a partner and four children, owed the council more than £3,500 in unpaid rent.

She could have claimed £15,000 a year in housing benefit to pay the rent, but had not made a proper application.

The council started eviction proceedings, but Miss Powell appealed under the Human Rights Act.

While awaiting the result of court action, the family moved out of their home so the council could  pay for renovating the property, then  they moved back in.

The human rights thinking is landlords cannot evict tenants under any circumstances if they have not considered where they will live once they leave.

Private landlords with local housing benefit tenants worry that benefit changes later this year that reduce the cash tenants receive from a council to pay their rents could lead to rising arrears problems.

If so, landlords could face subsidising tenants who do not pay the rent out of their own pockets because they cannot evict them.

Is the law completely mad?  Don’t landlords have human rights too?

The latest arrears estimates from LSL Property Services, a leading letting agent, puts unpaid rent owed to landlords just for December at £276 million.


Mark Alexander - Founder of Property118 View Profile

8:28 AM, 7th April 2011, About 11 years ago

Mick, sorry to hear that you are having these problems. However, you are definitely NOT allowed to stay in the property. Doing so could get you blacklisted on a number of tenant referencing sites and that would make life very difficult for you to rent elsewhere in the future. For whatever reason your landlord wants to let to somebody else but he's not going to be able to do so without a Gas Safe check. You will have to move out but you could report the situation regarding the Gas Check to your local trading standards officer. Good luck with the search for your new home and I hope your next landlord is more accommodating. Ideally you need to find out why your landlord is letting the property and how many others he lets. If it's the only one he has and he's renting it because it's not practical to live there that's where I find most problems like this come from. On the other hand, if a landlord has lots of properties and is in the business for the long term you are less likely to have such problems as these as the landlord has a reputation to protect. Maybe you could ask the landlord or the letting agent for references from the landlords existing tenants? I've been asked for this in the past and my feeling is that if my prospective tenants are checking me out at the same time as I'm checking them out it bodes well for a quality long standing relationship. As a professional landlord I'm always looking for good long term tenants who will let me know if anything needs to be maintained to protect my investment. GOOD LUCK!



Leave Comments

In order to post comments you will need to Sign In or Sign Up for a FREE Membership


Don't have an account? Sign Up

Landlord Tax Planning Book Now