Where’s the bloody great risk warning on BTL?
One question has been nagging at me. Why doesn’t buy-to-let come with a massive risk warning?
Picture the card in the estate agent’s window. A house for £250,000. Annual rent of £20,000. Across the top, in letters you can read from the other side of the road: “FANTASTIC INVESTMENT OPPORTUNITY – 8% YIELD.”
I’d like equal space on that card for this:
Suppose I buy that house in my own name. I put down £50,000 and borrow £200,000 on an interest-only mortgage at 6%. My tenant pays the full £20,000. Running costs come to £5,000 and the bank takes £12,000 in interest. I make that £3,000 profit.
Now suppose the whole £15,000 before interest falls in my 40% tax band. Under HMRC’s mortgage interest rules, my Income Tax bill is £6,000 less a £2,400 credit. That leaves £3,600 to pay.
For every pound I’ve actually made from letting that house, I owe HMRC £1.20.
Nobody missed a rent payment. Nothing went particularly wrong. I put up fifty grand, took responsibility for somebody’s home for a whole year and it cost me £600 for the privilege. Which bit of the estate agent’s card would have told me that?
Perhaps the house price will go up. I rather need it to. If it falls by 10%, half my £50,000 deposit is gone. If it falls by 20%, the house is worth exactly what I owe the bank. The estate agent and solicitor will still want paying when I sell.
Then there’s the peculiar business of being a landlord. Spend Sunday finding a plumber because water is coming through a tenant’s ceiling and HMRC allows you nothing for your own time. Die on Monday and an ordinary buy-to-let portfolio generally gets no Business Relief for Inheritance Tax either. Yet while you’re alive and running it, you’d better know precisely which licence you need.
In England, certain housing offences can attract a civil penalty of up to £40,000. For qualifying offences, a tribunal can order a landlord to repay up to two years’ rent.
Two years’ rent. On the house in that window, that’s £40,000. It would take more than thirteen years to earn that much in profit, even before the taxman had a penny.
So when somebody asks whether buy-to-let pays better than an FSCS-protected savings account, I’d like to know which figure they’re comparing with the bank interest. The £20,000 on the card? The £3,000 in the accounts? Or the £600 I’ve just had to find from my wages? I’ve yet to hear of a bank ringing a saver on Christmas Eve because the boiler’s packed up, and I haven’t even opened the leaseholder’s five-figure major works bill or the lender’s letter explaining how much the mortgage will cost when the fixed rate ends.
I’m barely scraping the surface!
If that estate agent gave you one line in the window, what warning would you write from your own experience?
2 comments on this article
Learn from your peers’ experience
A different perspective could help you spot an issue, avoid a mistake or find a better way forward. Read the comments and add your own views if you wish.
Previous Article
The landlord register: what it will ask for, and how to get ready
Member Since December 2023 - Comments: 1669
9:48 AM, 18th November 2026, About 17 minutes ago
Nailed it.
The government is stealing money from landlords.
Member Since October 2020 - Comments: 1428
9:59 AM, 18th November 2026, About 6 minutes ago
Thank you for this article. I’ve been saying the same thing for years. People still believe that owning a rental property is the best way to a non contributory pension pot and they don’t properly run the numbers or consider the regulatory risks. The era of the amateur landlord was over some time ago, but no-one has warned the public, possibly because all those in a position to have their voice heard on the issue have a vested interest in the status quo.