The invisible cage keeping landlords from the life they worked for
For nearly four decades, I helped landlords build their wealth, while most of my time is now spent helping them work out how to enjoy it. Behind the questions about selling properties and paying tax lies a much bigger question about whether they can give themselves permission to live differently and put a practical plan in place to make that possible.
There are two very different pictures I want to put in front of you this Sunday, both involving people who have worked hard, built wealth and reached a point in life where they would like more freedom. Their expectations about what they can do next are very different.
In one picture are landlords who feel they will remain in the rental business until the day they die. They would like to travel, spend more time with their families and shed some responsibility, yet every thought of doing so leads to another unanswered question, until staying exactly where they are feels like the only realistic choice.
In the other are friends I have made during more than 11 years of living abroad, many of whom have achieved financial and location independence. They can choose where to live, how to spend their time and how much of it to share with the people they love, having made a transition that the first group still struggles to imagine.
One friend bought a yacht and has the financial means to help his children buy their own homes and make it possible for them to sail around the Mediterranean with him without needing to work. He can share his wealth, enjoy their company and see the difference it makes while he is here to experience it.
Among those friends who have made the transition, the refrain is the same: they should have done it sooner. That stays with me, because so much of my working life now involves conversations with people who cannot yet see how to make a similar change.
The work that has changed
For nearly four decades, I have helped landlords build and optimise their rental property businesses. Over the last two years, around 90% of my time has been spent helping them dismantle those businesses, protect and enjoy their wealth, reduce risk and prepare a legacy their children actually want to inherit.
The direction of this change has come from the landlords themselves. They are arriving with questions about selling, retirement and succession because those are the things they now want help with.
They want to know which properties to sell first and why, understand the Capital Gains Tax position, establish what will remain after mortgages and costs, and work out where to park the money afterwards. They also want to know what could replace the rental income and whether they can afford to stop doing so much.
They also want examples of how other landlords have reduced their risks and responsibilities, organised their finances and decided what to keep. They are interested in how much time those landlords now spend with their families and what an ordinary week looks like after making the transition.
I think those questions belong together, because a calculation of sale proceeds has much more meaning when you know what you want those proceeds to make possible. An appealing picture of retirement becomes useful when you understand how you could afford it.
These are the conversations our team of four Property118 consultants is here to help with, and I am one of that team. My three colleagues are every bit as capable of helping you make sense of your position and the choices ahead.
How the invisible cage takes shape
The cage is usually a collection of questions that have never been brought together and properly answered. The tax might be substantial and the borrowing complicated, while the income feels essential, the alternatives are unfamiliar and the family has never discussed any of it.
Each concern sends you back to the business you know, where there is a repair to approve, a mortgage to review or an email that needs answering. Those things feel immediate and understandable, while working out what you want from the next 20 years feels harder to fit into the diary.
Another year passes as you deal with everything that needs doing. The life you hoped the business would eventually provide stays on the other side of the bars while those familiar responsibilities continue to occupy your time.
Familiarity can make a demanding situation feel safer than an unfamiliar alternative, especially when you know what a leaking roof involves. You may have much less confidence about managing a substantial sum outside property or deciding how much you can spend in retirement, which makes the hesitation understandable.
There may also be pride involved because you built this business through your own judgement and effort. Selling part of it can feel strangely uncomfortable when you are accustomed to measuring progress through what you acquire and improve, even if doing so would serve a purpose you value.
Tax, debt and income requirements deserve serious attention when assessing what is affordable. Establishing that something is unaffordable gives you a clearer basis for a decision than living for years with an untested assumption that it must be.
What freedom would look like for you
The yacht is one person’s version of the life he wants, while your ambitions may be entirely different. Perhaps you would like to spend several weeks visiting children overseas, or take the grandchildren away while they are still young enough to think a holiday with you is an adventure.
You might want a winter somewhere warm, time to learn a language or the freedom to accept an invitation without first thinking about the next property problem. You may simply want to spend more unhurried time with your partner, after years in which the business has occupied so much of your attention.
Try picturing an ordinary Tuesday, including where you would wake up, what you would do after breakfast, who you would see and what you would be pleased no longer to have to deal with. A satisfying retirement has to work on ordinary days as well as during the memorable holidays.
Financial independence can give you the ability to choose how much work you do, while location independence can give you more choice about where you do it. You might still enjoy projects, helping other people or keeping an interest in property, with the attraction being greater control over your commitments.
There is something particularly appealing about being able to help your family while you can share in the result. A contribution towards a home, a family holiday or more time together has a human value that never appears in a portfolio valuation and deserves a place in the planning.
Imagine being able to extend a visit because you are enjoying it, or to spend a weekday with a grandchild without mentally rearranging everything else. Those are modest freedoms, but they can change the texture of a life. The opportunity is to decide which experiences matter to you and give them proper consideration alongside the financial figures.
The conversation many families have never had
What still amazes me is how many landlords have never had a proper conversation with their families about what they want. They have worked for years with their partner and children in mind, yet much of the intended future rests on assumptions.
A partner may want less responsibility, while an adult child may be proud of what you have achieved and still have no desire to become a landlord. Another may be interested if the business is organised in a way they can manage, and each of those preferences deserves to be heard.
It can be difficult for children to say any of this when they worry that expressing a preference for something simpler will sound ungrateful. They may assume that you would be hurt if they sold the properties, while you assume that their silence means they are happy with your plans.
Begin by asking what they would actually welcome and give them room to answer honestly. You could explore whether they want to run the business, would prefer assets they could divide and manage independently, or would welcome help now that could make a greater difference to their lives.
Your own future also deserves discussion, including how your partner would like the next few years to look and whether you are both still enjoying the business. It is worth establishing how much you consider enough, particularly if you are continuing towards a target that neither of you has ever defined.
You may discover that your family would be delighted to see you enjoy more of what you have earned, or that they do want to continue the business. Either answer gives you useful information on which to build a plan, based on a conversation about their wishes.
Could you take over your best friend’s property business
Imagine your best friend owns a rental property business of a similar size to yours. Over the years, you have discussed tenants, mortgages, repairs and the frustrations of being a landlord, so you have a reasonable idea of what they own, although you have never needed to understand the detail.
One day, they tell you they have been diagnosed with a terminal illness and have been told they have less than a year to live. They ask whether you would help get everything organised for their family, but as the conversation continues, you realise they are already too ill to do much themselves and would need you to take responsibility for almost everything.
You would naturally want to help, but where would you begin? Before you could make sensible decisions, you would need to establish what they own, how the borrowing is arranged, what income the properties produce, where the records are kept and what their family would actually want to happen to the business.
Even with your experience, how comfortable would you feel deciding which properties should be retained, whether any should be sold and who could take over the management? You would also have to fit this around your own business and family, knowing that your friend was relying on you and that the time available might be shorter than anyone hoped.
Now imagine the same responsibility falling to your children after your death. They may have none of your experience, no interest in becoming landlords and very little understanding of the business you have spent years building, yet they would be trying to make sense of it while grieving for you.
If you would struggle to take over your best friend’s property business while they were still alive, how well have you prepared your loved ones to take over yours when you are gone?
You would also discover how much of your friend’s knowledge had never needed to be written down. An expensive repair they were expecting, the reason for retaining a particular property or the history behind a tenant’s circumstances could all affect decisions that somebody else was now being asked to make.
The family would need to know where accessible cash could be found and what had to be paid while the estate was being dealt with. Where inheritance tax is payable, the normal payment deadline is the end of the sixth month after death, and a payment is usually needed before probate can be granted.
Tax attributable to qualifying property can be paid in ten annual instalments, with the first due at that same deadline. Interest generally applies to the outstanding tax on ordinary rental property, and selling the property brings the remaining tax attributable to it into payment, so the family would still need a workable funding plan.
A lender’s requirements will depend on the borrowing and circumstances, while the tax position will depend on the estate. Assuming the family can sort everything out later leaves them to discover the answers at a difficult time.
The darker side of the invisible cage is that, if you never examine how to leave it, the unresolved decisions may eventually pass to someone else. The people you most wanted to protect could inherit a collection of responsibilities they were never prepared to take on.
The basics that keep being postponed
I also encounter landlords with no Will, no Lasting Powers of Attorney and no life insurance. Important decisions about who should receive their wealth, who could act for them during their lifetime and how money might be available when needed have remained on the list of things to sort out.
A Will addresses what should happen after death, while a power of attorney deals with decisions during your lifetime. In England and Wales, Lasting Powers of Attorney can appoint people to help with or make specified decisions, including if you lose capacity, with different arrangements applying in Scotland and Northern Ireland. This authority ends on death, so the arrangements for administering your estate need separate attention.
Without a valid Will, the applicable intestacy rules determine entitlement. Even where a Will exists, it needs to be considered alongside the assets, ownership arrangements and wishes it is intended to address. A document written years ago deserves attention when life or the business has changed.
Life insurance is a separate discussion about whether suitable cover could help meet a need for money, taking account of cost, eligibility, ownership and purpose. The useful starting point is to identify what your family would need and what resources would be available, then obtain appropriate advice.
These matters remain relevant if you intend to keep every property. You can make the business easier for someone else to understand and improve the arrangements around it while continuing to enjoy running it yourself.
Turning property wealth into usable choices
A portfolio valuation and the balance of equity provide only part of the information needed to establish what you could spend after a sale. Borrowing, transaction costs and tax all need to be considered, together with the ownership arrangements.
Start with the income the business actually provides, bearing in mind that your household lives on what remains after costs and tax. Gross rent is a useful operating figure, while repairs, management, finance and irregular expenditure all matter when assessing how dependable that income is.
Then look at the equity committed to producing that income and consider how the property’s current return compares with the capital tied up in it. A property that has risen substantially in value may still be worth retaining, with the work involved and the risks you are accepting forming part of that assessment.
Your time belongs in that discussion because, even where an agent handles the day-to-day management, you may still carry the financial decisions and ultimate responsibility. If those decisions occupy more of your thoughts than you want, that is a relevant cost to you.
The rest of your finances matter too, because pensions, savings, other investments, your home and financial commitments can change the picture considerably. The amount you want to spend, the help you hope to give your family and the reserves you want to retain also need to be considered.
Once those things are set out together, keeping the business, reducing it gradually or making a more complete exit can be examined against the same objectives. You remain the person deciding which outcome you want, with the comparison helping you assess the choices available.
When the tax bill becomes the strongest bar
Capital Gains Tax can loom so large in someone’s mind that the conversation stops before the figure has been calculated properly. A rough estimate becomes a reason to keep everything indefinitely, without comparing what would remain after selling with the cost and benefit of continuing.
The amount needs to be established using the right information, including examination of the gain, relevant costs and available reliefs for personally owned property. If a company owns the property, Corporation Tax on a chargeable gain may apply instead, with separate questions about taking money out of the company.
That work is needed to arrive at a reliable picture of the money available under each realistic option. The timing of liabilities and reporting obligations needs attention as well as the amount.
You might decide that a sale is worthwhile after allowing for tax, prefer a phased approach that better suits your needs, or retain particular assets because the figures and family plans support doing so. The appropriate choice depends on what that examination establishes about your finances and the outcome you want.
Tax needs to be considered alongside the life you could afford after paying it and the income, risks and responsibilities you would retain by continuing. The objective is to understand the consequences well enough to choose with confidence.
Choosing what to sell and how
It is tempting to begin with whichever property has caused the latest problem. That may turn out to be the right choice, but it is worth looking beyond the most recent frustration. Another property could be producing a weaker return, facing substantial expenditure or releasing more useful capital on sale.
The order needs to account for income, borrowing, tax, condition, marketability and your timetable. Selling an easy property first might make progress possible; it could also leave you with a more demanding collection of assets. What remains after each step matters just as much as what has been sold.
Tenants belong in the plan, with their homes, the legal position and the practical sale route needing careful consideration. A sale with tenants in place may be an option in some circumstances, but the price, likely buyers and transaction terms need to be understood.
Property118 has published an account of Shirley McLean selling four properties to another landlord. In that account, published by Landlord Sales Agency, she described accepting a price compromise to avoid the uncertainty and potential carrying costs of a prolonged series of sales, while keeping her tenants in place.
Another account from the same agency described Shauna selling 23 properties and retaining ten. These are individual sale experiences, rather than a formula for anyone else’s price or timetable. They illustrate how different a decision to reduce a portfolio can look in practice.
For your own plan, give thought to the endpoint and, if the intention is to keep a few properties, decide what would make them suitable for the life you want. Otherwise, a gradual exit can become an extended process with no clear point at which the desired freedom actually arrives.
A useful plan can describe the stages, what the first sales would achieve, how the remaining business would operate and when you would reassess the income and your appetite for continuing. Breaking the work into stages can make a large change easier to examine, with opportunities to review the details as the plan develops.
Where the money goes afterwards
For someone who has spent decades buying property, a substantial amount of cash can feel unfamiliar. The bricks and mortar were tangible and the rent arrived regularly, whereas selling raises a new set of decisions about security, access and income.
Money needed for tax and near-term spending should be considered separately from money intended to support later years. Where to hold sale proceeds while considering your options is a different question from how to organise a long-term retirement plan.
Even temporary arrangements deserve thought, with access, the account holder and applicable protection all needing attention. FSCS deposit protection depends on eligibility and banking authorisation; different brand names can share one banking licence, so a large balance merits a deliberate arrangement.
For the longer term, the discussion needs to consider income requirements, inflation, access to capital, risk and how long the money may need to support you. Existing pensions and investments belong in that picture, with appropriate regulated financial advice helping you assess the choices against your circumstances.
Planning this alongside the sales and understanding what could happen to the proceeds helps answer the fear that selling means stepping into the unknown. The arrangements should make sense to you, including their costs, limitations and risks.
The part that never appears in the accounts
I want to hear more from landlords about life after the transition, including how the first few months felt and whether they missed the business. The sale itself is only one part of the story, alongside adjusting to a different pattern of income and a diary with fewer obligations.
Most of all, I would like to know what they have done with the time and how much more often they see their families. I would also be interested in whether they have taken the trip they kept postponing, are enjoying a smaller business or have discovered interests they had little room for before.
Those accounts deserve to include the adjustments as well as the pleasures, because a business can provide purpose, routine and a sense of achievement. Planning for retirement involves thinking about what will fill the space it leaves, alongside the financial arrangements.
My friends’ experiences make the possibilities feel real to me, because their freedom gives them choices about family, travel and how they spend their days. The life they enjoy helps explain why making the transition matters to them.
For readers without children, the same questions about enjoyment and responsibility still apply. Your priorities may involve a partner, friends, other relatives or causes you care about. The future should reflect your wishes, including who you would want to benefit and who could help carry them out.
You may also read this while still building enthusiastically. Understanding your eventual destination can help you decide what to acquire, what responsibilities to accept and how to organise the business now. The question of what the wealth is for has value long before retirement.
A Sunday worth setting aside
If you recognise yourself in any of this, give the subject some uninterrupted time and begin with a blank page describing the life you would like over the next few years. Be specific enough that somebody else could understand what more freedom means to you, whether that is three months abroad, two afternoons a week with grandchildren or simply fewer financial decisions.
Write down what you would like to stop doing as well, because those responsibilities can be easier to identify than an ideal retirement. It is also worth considering what you would still enjoy keeping, because the right outcome may include some continuing involvement.
Have the family conversation while those thoughts are fresh, sharing this article if it helps explain why you are asking. Listen to what the people closest to you would welcome and where their wishes differ from what you assumed, leaving room for a second conversation if they need time to think.
Next, document the financial position by gathering the property details, ownership information, realistic value estimates, borrowing, rents and costs, together with the rest of your assets and commitments. Identify estimates clearly and record what you do not yet know, so the information provides a useful starting picture of your position.
Finally, note the arrangements that already exist, including where the Will is kept, whether relevant powers of attorney are in place and what insurance is held. Recording who understands the business and where its records can be found makes the gaps visible enough to discuss sensibly.
Preparation takes effort, and if assembling the information feels difficult with your own knowledge available, consider what it might be like for someone else to reconstruct it without you. The preparation has value before any property is sold because it helps make your affairs easier to understand.
A consultation with the Property118 team
A £400 Property118 consultation gives you dedicated time with one of our four consultants to discuss where you are now, what you want from life and the questions that need resolving. The information you prepare helps your consultant make that conversation specific to you.
I am proud to recommend each of my three colleagues and have every confidence in their ability to help you examine your choices. Whichever of us you speak to, you should feel able to talk openly about your ambitions, ask the questions that have been holding you back and explore what needs to happen next.
The consultation is a starting point, with detailed analysis, legal or tax work and regulated financial advice potentially needed afterwards, depending on your circumstances and the direction you choose. Understanding what further work is required is part of moving from a broad ambition towards an informed plan.
Come prepared to think as well as to provide figures, and be candid about what worries you, which responsibilities you want to shed and what you would like your wealth to make possible. If you are unsure what you want, identifying that uncertainty is a useful beginning.
When I think about my friend sailing with his children, I think about the time they can share while he is there to enjoy it. The imagined conversation with a seriously ill friend asks us to consider how much harder decisions can become when that time is running out.
Before you put this article aside, consider whether you would feel comfortable handing your own property business to that friend tomorrow, with only the information and arrangements you currently have in place. If the answer is no, think about what would need to change before you could reasonably expect your loved ones to manage it without you.
Set aside time to prepare and begin the conversation with your family. Give the life you worked for a chance to become more than something you hope to enjoy one day.
BOOK YOUR £400 CONSULTATION TODAY
Be the first to comment
Your experience could help the next reader
Have you dealt with something similar? Share what you learned, raise a question or offer a perspective your peers may find useful.
Previous Article
Labour wants the keys to YOUR landlord properties
Not a member yet? Join In Seconds
Login with