If landlords want out, who is supposed to buy?
If a landlord has decided that a rental property no longer justifies the money, work and risk involved, why should another landlord pay the asking price to take it on? There might be sensible answers to that question, but I think we need to hear more of them.
Our recent report on the rise in tenanted properties listed for sale left me wondering about the other side of these potential transactions. The figures quoted suggest that the number being advertised increased from 7,119 in October to 7,296 in November.
I can understand why landlords might want to sell. What I would like to understand is why another landlord would want to buy, particularly at the price the seller hopes to achieve.
The company argument only goes so far
Suppose a landlord has reviewed their mortgage costs, maintenance expenditure, tax position and continuing responsibilities, and concluded that the property no longer provides a worthwhile return. They have also worked out what would remain after repaying the mortgage, meeting selling costs and paying any Capital Gains Tax due.
Perhaps they have considered having their own limited company buy the property. Having examined the SDLT, legal fees, financing arrangements and tax consequences applicable to their circumstances, they have decided that this would not produce an attractive enough outcome either.
At that point, simply saying that another landlord could buy through a company does not fully answer the question.
Companies are outside the finance-cost restriction affecting individual residential landlords, and that can make a significant difference. However, in this example the seller has already considered company ownership. The incoming buyer still needs to fund the purchase, meet acquisition costs and operate the property under the applicable letting rules.
Any CGT on the outgoing landlord’s historic gain is the seller’s responsibility. That does not improve the incoming buyer’s rental income or remove their own costs.
What, then, makes the proposition sufficiently different for the buyer?
Different buyers can reach different conclusions
There are perfectly sensible reasons for two people to reach different decisions about the same property. A landlord approaching retirement may want less responsibility, greater liquidity and fewer demands on their time. Someone building a business over the next twenty years may be willing to take on precisely those responsibilities.
The buyer might also need substantially less borrowing, have funds already available within a company, or be able to manage the property efficiently alongside an existing local portfolio. Someone who can leave profits invested has different objectives from someone relying on the business to fund their personal spending.
Those differences can support a sensible transaction. Selling to an unrelated buyer also allows the outgoing landlord to relinquish their exposure to the property. Transferring it into their own company would leave them economically involved.
However, the differences need to be real. Even a cash buyer needs a worthwhile return on all the money committed, including SDLT and purchase costs. Having no mortgage does not make the capital free.
The price still has to work
A property that looks unattractive at £250,000 might look considerably more appealing at £200,000. The rent could be identical, but the buyer would have less capital committed and potentially less borrowing to service.
That raises an awkward question for the seller: are they prepared to accept the price at which another landlord can justify buying?
The seller’s desired retirement fund, outstanding mortgage or anticipated CGT bill cannot determine what the property is worth to the purchaser. The buyer needs to assess the actual tenancy, rent, condition, expenditure and likely return.
Equally, a lower offer changes the seller’s calculation. Once they know how little would be available to reinvest elsewhere, retaining the property may become more attractive than accepting the offer.
A reliable tenant and an established payment history can certainly have value. Nevertheless, describing a property as an investment opportunity does not establish that the asking price produces an adequate investment return.
The buyer who already calls it home
There is one particularly clear exception to the landlord-to-landlord comparison: the existing tenant buying the property as their own home.
Their reasons for buying are fundamentally different. They are considering the home they already occupy, the security of ownership and the prospect of building equity through mortgage repayments. Their calculation compares renting with the full costs of home ownership.
The difference in acquisition tax can be substantial. On a £250,000 purchase in England, an eligible first-time buyer acquiring their main home would pay no SDLT. A company buying the same property as an ordinary buy-to-let investment would normally pay £15,000 at the higher residential rates. That comparison assumes no non-resident surcharge or special relief.
The tenant might also qualify for a residential mortgage at a high loan-to-value. The government’s permanent mortgage guarantee scheme supports the availability of mortgages up to 95% loan-to-value for eligible homebuyers. The borrower and property must still meet the lender’s requirements, including affordability, and purchase costs need to be funded as well.
Ownership brings maintenance bills and other responsibilities, so buying will not suit every tenant. However, this is a purchaser whose decision does not depend on generating a taxable rental profit. I can readily understand why the same property could make sense as their home even when its owner has decided to leave the letting business.
Show us the completed sales
The figures in the original report concern properties being advertised. They do not establish how many are completing sales to other landlords, what prices are being achieved or what returns the purchasers expect.
An increase in available listings could reflect more owners coming to market, properties taking longer to sell, or a combination of the two. It does not, by itself, demonstrate that willing landlord buyers are absorbing them.
I would be interested to hear from landlords who are buying tenanted properties. What makes the numbers work for you? Is it the purchase price, your funding, lower operating costs, a longer investment horizon or something else?
If the next landlord faces broadly the same costs, taxes and responsibilities, what exactly makes this a good investment for them at the price the seller is asking?
Be the first to comment
Your experience could help the next reader
Have you dealt with something similar? Share what you learned, raise a question or offer a perspective your peers may find useful.
Previous Article
Landlord tax hikes spark rise in tenanted properties listed for sale
Not a member yet? Join In Seconds
Login with